Monday, November 27, 2006

The clue is in Leyte

WE have found some vital answers to the constant dilemma over the country’s poor educational system and they’re not in the glitzy, expensive, air-conditioned rooms of exclusive schools here in Metro Manila and other urban areas. It’s in the remote town of Tomas Oppus in Southern Leyte where visitors have to travel hours of unpaved roads just to get to Rizal National High School that recently topped the National Achievement Test for Freshmen Students.

Based on the story of this paper’s reporter Rommer Balaba, Rizal National High School (RNHS), being a public school, has nothing to show in terms of fancy gadgets and technology. But its teachers, parents and community leaders have the will and concern to ensure that students get to school and are taught properly despite the limited resources they have.

Asked about the reasons for the school’s success, Violeta Merin-Alocilja, Leyte’s division superintendent, had a short, self-explanatory answer: “Stakeholder participation, which includes the barangay leaders, parents, and local government executives, coupled with teacher dedication. There is a strong linkage between the school and the community. Parents, in particular, realized they have to give support either technically or financially so that teachers can focus on teaching.”

Now that—“stakeholder participation”—is really nothing. We often hear this word being mouthed by do-gooders and people who dream for change. The only difference is that people in Leyte took it seriously and voila, they got the high scores in areas such as English, mathematics, science, Filipino and social studies. It helped that the Asian Development Bank (ADB) provided soft loans in terms of teacher’s training, textbooks and new learning interventions. But that simply proves the point that given a little more resources and a lot of innovative community involvement, it’s possible for any school in the Philippines to raise its quality of education. There must be a way for the Department of Education to distill the lessons from this social experiment and upscale the efforts to the larger educational system so we could achieve drastic improvements in the quality of education in the Philippines.

We say we need drastic improvements in the country’s educational system because the Philippine economy, nay the entire world, is changing fast. In the last three years, the Philippine economy has been growing quite decently at 5 percent to 6 percent and there are indications it might yet achieve 7 percent a few years from now, and yet unemployment rate in the country has remained high at more than 8 percent. Why?

The usual reason is about “jobless growth” or the inability of the economy to generate enough jobs for the new entrants to the labor force, despite expansion in economic activities. Others say we are producing overqualified college-degree holders when all the economy needs is an army of skilled labor trained from vocational and technical schools.

Sounds valid enough but recent trends in the economy tend to show that these assumptions are no longer valid. Human-resource practitioners these days swear that jobs, whether abroad or within the country’s borders, are being created fast but employers are finding a hard time finding the people “with the right package.”

Main drivers of growth (like electronics and cyber services) these days require more flexible-knowledge workers that are not being provided by the country’s school system in greater numbers despite the rising number of students entering and leaving the school system. It’s not only that we are running short of skilled welders and pipe fitters; we are also running short of call-center agents, accountants, mining engineers, doctors, nurses, teachers, information-technology professionals, among many skills that require four or five-year college degrees or training.

The country will increasingly feel this problem as the Philippine economy goes up the value chain toward the “five-star outsourcing,” which includes analytics, market research, valuation research, investment research, online teaching, patent filing and media content supply.

And why this new trend? It’s because globalization has significantly transformed the workplace. Employers these days are increasingly dealing with global clients in a business environment that is changing fast and has become so diverse. Customers, most of them well-informed, are demanding. Organizational structures are flat, meaning that employees are expected to engage or get involved in decision making as corporate organizations compete and innovate.
That is why—according to the Personnel Management Association of the Philippines (PMAP)—the standards by which employers make hiring decisions have increased significantly. At the very least, they need three core competencies including excellent and written English, analytical and conceptual thinking, and initiative.

Employers, according to PMAP, need people who can write and speak excellent English with confidence, employees who can make presentations, and can understand foreign accents. They need people who can break down problems systematically, process large amounts of information, see consequences and implications, connect the dots, and make logical conclusions. In a highly competitive and fast-changing world, they need staff who persist in problem solving—people who do more than what are expected of them, and address problems before they are asked to.

In short, employers these days increasingly need dynamic-knowledge workers which the country’s school system is not providing in adequate numbers. For long, this country has suffered underinvestment in education. That’s the reason why we can’t seem to address unemployment amid economic expansion.

It is within this context that the Sogod experiment in Leyte is very important. Certainly, we need more schools with sophisticated facilities and highly trained teachers. But that takes a lot of resources and time. But we could still fast track the upgrading of the country’s educational system by learning what the people of Southern Leyte have done and take them to heart the way they did.

Thursday, November 23, 2006

Here's to women

Let us treat men and women well; treat them as if they were real. Perhaps they are.—Ralph Waldo Emerson

THE Philippines is probably the only country in the world where men call their women “commanders.” We thought all along that this is just a ruse by husbands to get into the kulambo after coming home reeking of booze until the World Economic Forum (WEF) released its gender gap report on Wednesday saying the Philippines ranks high—the only developing country—with those countries who give power and equality to women. And it’s a distinct honor for a country that has always been ranked lower in other measurements related to “competitiveness,” “economic freedom,” and “ease to do business” by several international institutions.

Besides the Philippines (ranked No. 6), countries in the top 10 include Sweden, Norway, Finland, Iceland, Germany, New Zealand, Denmark, United Kingdom and Ireland, in that order. These countries are on the honor roll for closing the gender gap between the sexes in four areas—namely, economic participation and opportunity (the outcomes on salaries, participation levels and access to high-skilled employment), educational attainment (access to basic and higher level education), political empowerment (representation in decision-making structures), and health and survival (life expectancy and sex ratio).

In short, while the Philippines is not as rich as these Nordic and European countries, our country has come a long way in terms of economic, political, educational and health opportunities to both men and women. In that aspect of life, the Philippines has come of age.

It used to be that parents would only send their boys to schools and the girls to the marriage altar. Not anymore. In fact, there seems to be more girls than boys in high-school and college campuses. An initial assessment of the country’s chances for attaining the Millennium Development Goals (MDG) by 2015 has shown that it is in gender equality in school where the Philippines has excelled, even before reckoning time. Moreover, women are now represented in all levels of government and layers of the corporate world.

At the same time, women live longer than men these days!

WEF’s Gender Gap Index report, therefore, is a fitting tribute to Filipino women, who, for a long time, have been carrying the heavier burdens of saving this country from economic damnation.
Now, to say they are carrying the “heavier” load would probably make the Filipino machos in our midst shudder. But statistics do support this assertion. If one looks at our economic statistics more closely, one would realize that more than 60 percent of the country’s gross domestic product is accounted for by the “globalized” sector of the Philippine economy.

We are talking here of the export sector (the bulk of which is electronics), outsourcing and overseas employment that have been propping up consumption. Many of the warm bodies in these economic sectors are women.

In the last decade, the Philippines has been sending more and more skilled professionals, which account for the double-digit growth rates in remittances. More than 60 percent of these newly deployed overseas workers are women essentially because developed countries need an ever-increasing number of nurses, caregivers and therapists (careers still dominated by women) to care for their graying population.

If one looks closely at the country’s national income accounts, one could see that “personal consumption expenditure” accounts for more than 70 percent of the country’s GDP or the value of goods and services produced, traded and paid for within the country’s borders.
Inasmuch as the Philippine overseas employment has been “feminized” it’s easy to assume that women have significantly helped in sustaining the jobs in factories, offices and shopping malls.
Indeed, the authors of WEF’s gender gap report did not write the report out of sheer sentimentalism. They prepared it with real economic sense in mind.

Said Laura Tyson, dean of the London Business School and one of the principal authors of the report: “Our work shows a strong correlation between GDP per capita and the gender gap scores. While this does not imply causality, the possible theoretical underpinnings of this link are quite simple: countries that do not fully capitalize effectively on one-half of their human resources run the risk of undermining their competitive potential. We hope to highlight the economic incentive behind empowering women in addition to promoting equality as a basic human right.”

It’s one facet of our economic development that the Philippines needs to nurture. And it’s not only because we love our mothers, wives, daughters and sisters, but also because it makes so much economic sense for all men and women to do so.

And certainly, despite the plaudits given us by WEF, we need to do more to address the remaining gender gaps especially in issues like domestic violence and rape, among others.
The past few years we have made great strides in legislating better protection for women—against sexual harassment in the workplace, against domestic violence, and against discriminatory provisions in civil law.

Yet by the very nature of our economic strategy of encouraging the wholesale export of workers, we still have to mainstream protective measures for Filipino migrant women. Trafficking in women, especially in minors, becomes easy because of weak enforcement despite tougher laws against trafficking per se and against passport falsification. Each day hundreds of minors are lured by syndicates to nonexistent jobs in the Middle East and Southeast Asia, especially, given falsified passports to hide their true age, and then shipped off to brothels—from where, often, the only way to freedom is a perilous escape. No wonder they come back with broken bones, and worse, broken spirits, if not in boxes.

Unless we can address fully these outstanding issues, we cannot completely bring out the champagne over the WEF report. Yes, we’ve joined the ranks of First-World countries, but we keep dark secrets that must be purged decisively.

Monday, November 20, 2006

The Philippines needs a new economic story line

THE National Statistical Coordination Board (NSCB) and the National Economic and Development Authority (Neda) will announce the third-quarter performance of the Philippine economy on Wednesday, November 29. But don’t expect any surprises there. Romulo Neri, Neda’s secretary-general, is going to say that the Philippines has achieved a higher GDP growth rate—probably 5.8 percent—fueled by OFWs’ remittances, consumption, higher exports and good farm harvests.

It’s the same old story we have been hearing in the last several quarters that will not have any bearing whether or not there would be less jobless people in the streets. We need a fresh story line to convince us that we are gaining real grounds instead of the illusory 5 percent to 6 percent growth-rate band that has yet to curb the rising unemployment numbers.

Lest we are misunderstood, we would like to stress here that we welcome the numbers showing the Philippine economy is indeed moving forward. The 6.5-percent GDP growth rate in the first quarter of the year is nothing to sneeze at. These are good numbers indicating that the Philippine economy may have left behind the era of boom and bust cycles that characterized the Philippine economy following the Edsa Revolution. In fact, there seems to be new growth drivers emerging in our midst including cyberservices, electronics, agribusiness, aquaculture, furniture, high-fashion garments, mining, shipbuilding, tourism, hotels and restaurants. Even the World Bank, traditionally not enthusiastic about the Philippines’ economic prospects, has recently issued a press statement saying the Philippines is on track to achieve 5.5-percent growth rate in 2006 and 5.7 percent in 2007despite the high probability of an external slowdown.

The World Bank here is saying that the Philippine economy has achieved certain resilience. And we have to thank overseas workers for that, as well as the entrepreneurs who persevered despite the continuing political turmoil and deteriorating infrastructure.

While Malacañang was busy putting out political fires, OFWs and business people tried all their best to move on. That’s the source of the country’s economic strength these days.
But we call these encouraging economic numbers “illusory” because they continue to signal several points of vulnerability. For one, we still owe much of these nice economic numbers to God, or sheer luck. In the last several years, the weather has been generally generous to the farm sector. That’s one big reason why the agricultural sector has been able to grow at 4 percent to 5 percent. Exports have been buoyant but this trend owes much to the rising global demand for electronics. New toys and gadgets these days (e.g. smart cars, third- or fourth-generation cellular phones, high-tech consumer durables) need higher and better electronic parts and we are benefiting from these new trends simply because we have lots of electronics and semiconductor firms within our borders, many of which have been here for more than 20 years.

And it’s illusory simply because these numbers have yet to make a dent on joblessness as shown by the latest labor force survey. The National Statistics Office (NSO) says that the country’s labor force grew by 2.6 percent, yet new jobs grew only by 2.3 percent.

Underemployment rose to almost 23.5 percent in July this year from 20.5 percent a year ago. In the second quarter, the Philippine agricultural sector grew by 6.7 percent, yet the labor force survey says the sector has lost 149,000 jobs. Yes, even agriculture is suffering from a “jobless growth”! Is it because of greater mechanization? That is not borne out by statistics either.
If we want to be certain about our growth and development prospects, if we want these numbers to translate to jobs for warm bodies, we need to hear about a real fresh story line. That story line is about investments becoming the major source of economic growth, about the policy measures and initiatives that could spur the Philippine economy toward a 7-percent to 8-percent growth. Experts say that’s the only growth level where we could start feeling that life has gone for the better.

The investment numbers so far—US$1.36 billion in the first eight months of the year—seem to be encouraging but are nowhere near the scale with which we see the massive building up of factories and shops that will hire thousands of people off the streets. And that’s only possible if the government could move faster in upgrading the country’s infrastructure. In pursuit of “fiscal consolidation” the government has totally neglected infrastructure development such that the Philippines now has the lousiest stock of infrastructure in the Asia-Pacific Region. In her last State of the Nation Address, President Arroyo announced a massive infrastructure program to address this matter—but we have yet to see things moving.

Besides infrastructure development, the government—with the help of the private sector—should really do something fast about the deteriorating educational system. We are not only talking about graduates who can speak good English. We are talking about a serious upgrade of our education and training in science and technology. And soon. We are currently experiencing jobless growth and deteriorating underemployment and that’s because economic growth these days is largely technology-driven. If we don’t plug this gap, we could never stop joblessness from deteriorating.

To repeat, we need a new story line. That should be less about remittances propping up consumption, but more about investments in factories and shops that create real jobs and better lives for many Filipinos.

Wednesday, November 08, 2006

On a journey down under

Ive been on the road here in Australia so i really havent had the time to update this blog until now. i didnt bring any laptop with me thinking that the hotels would provide free internet. late last year, i was in the US and the hotels provided free internet access. big mistake! in sydney, for instance, internet rates run as high as 5 australian dollars in 30 minutes. the cheapest i got was 5 AUD in an hour. that's too expensive for me. i had this chance to update because the Australian National University economics department provided me free internet. got to go!

Wednesday, November 01, 2006

SWS's self rated poverty surveys and the South Beach Diet

There are lies, damned lies, and statistics (Benjamin Disraeli).

Is it possible for poverty incidence to decline yet hunger incidence to rise? Sounds crazy but, yes its possible, says the Social Weather Stations (SWS) in it’s
latest survey result.

“The record high 16.9% of families experiencing hunger at least once in the past
three months was reached again in September 2006, according to the new SWS
survey. This amounts to 2.9 million households experiencing hunger out of a
projected base of 17.4 million households in the country.

“The latest poll, conducted from September 24 to October 2, also found 51% reporting themselves as Mahirap or Poor, compared to 59% in the previous quarter.”

If you are getting rich, would you say you experienced hunger? Probably not, unless you were on a South Beach diet. So SWS is telling us to not worry about experiencing hunger because we are probably getting rich. Funny.

SWS’s explanation for this contradictory result is even funnier. In its press release, SWS said the reason lies in the poverty threshold, or the amount of money needed for families escape poverty. SWS claims that over time Filipinos poverty threshold has been steady or even declining.

“The Median Self-Rated Poverty threshold, or the median monthly budget in
peso-terms that poor households say they need to escape poverty, went down in
Metro Manila, from P15,000 in June 2006 to P10,000 in September 2006, and in
Mindanao, from P6,000 to P5,000. It stayed at P6,000 in the Visayas and went up
in Balance of Luzon, from P5,000 to P6,000.”


Thus, it’s conclusion?

“Such money-value thresholds were already attained some years ago, even though
the cost of living increased greatly every year. Since the money-cost of living
is actually rising, a declining or unchanging poverty threshold means that
households are lowering their living standards, or belt-tightening.”

Cute, but is it logical? If you are force to do belt-tightening, would you say your economic standing is improving? I don’t think so.

If your financial requirement to escape poverty is the same or declining over the years (it certainly is declining due to inflation), does it mean you are belt-tightening? Not necessarily. It’s possible that your incomes, the basis for which you say you are no longer poor, is increasing. It’s possible that some members of the family got a job, hence the lower financial requirement.

SWS say the declining poverty threshold says people are “lowering their standards.” Probably. But would a people “lowering their standards” and economic expectations likely to say they are no longer poor? I don’t think so.

Based on SWS’s own historical data, it appears hunger has been on the decline reaching as low as close to 5 percent. But in the same period, the self-rated poverty threshold has been sizzling high at about 10,000 pesos. During the same period, SWS’s self-rated poverty was also on the downtrend. Using SWS’s explanation, how could a people say they are less and less suffering from hunger and poverty when their financial requirements to escape poverty are rising?

Something must be wrong somewhere. Let’s take those self-rated poverty surveys with a grain of salt!

Monday, October 30, 2006

Fiscal perks: giving away the nation's birth right!

NOW that the Board of Investments (BOI) and the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) have admitted that they were giving tax holidays to every Tom, Dick and Harry without asking why, it’s high time for Congress to take over and launch a thorough investigation on the matter.

Right now, Congress is trying to reform the country’s fiscal incentive system through the “fiscal rationalization” bill and it would help if they first get to the bottom of this issue. Congress should do it not just “in aid of legislation” but in pursuit of economic equity and social justice!

The other day, Trade Undersecretary Elmer Hernandez told our reporter Max de Leon that some companies are enjoying income tax holiday despite the fact that they are not eligible to get these perks. Each year, the country loses about P300 billion in forgone revenues—and part of this forgone amount goes to those who don’t deserve them because, as Hernandez admitted, many of those who availed themselves of the fiscal perks were not entitled to them.

Hernandez said the government lost billions because the BIR just allowed income tax holiday claims in their income tax returns even without proof from the BOI that the claimants were really eligible for the perks. He seems to be telling us that it’s just a simple, honest mistake, or one caused by sheer inability of state agencies to get their act together or streamline their systems owing to the great burden of their work.

We don’t think so. We believe a large part of such neglect grows out of corruption that has been plaguing the country’s fiscal-incentive system since the last several decades.

We don’t think bureaucrats from the BOI and the BIR are people who are naïve enough to allow these shenanigans to get through under their noses unless some people deep within these bureaucracies are benefiting financially from it.

The questions right now are the following: What are those companies that stole from the country’s coffers? Who in the BIR approved their ITH claims? How much money did the country lose to what companies since the President Aquino Executive Order 226? And why is it that BOI doesn’t seem to have any idea about how the country’s incentives system is being implemented? How about the Peza’s incentive system? These are questions that boggle our mind.

This blatant abuse of the fiscal incentives system is almost criminal. For years, the country, nay the Filipino people, have been suffering from poverty and lack of economic opportunities for the simple reason that the State could not provide good economic and social infrastructure. Bureaucrats have been telling us ordinary mortals that the government needs to collect more taxes “to finance development” and we were foolish enough to agree to a higher VAT rate on all the things we buy with our slave wages. Little did we know that while these bureaucrats were taking away food from the mouths of our children, they gave away hundreds of billions of pesos worth of income tax holidays to favored friends and clients, including to ones not entitled to the fiscal perks in the first place.

God knows how much money bureaucrats from the BIR and the BOI and other “investments promotions agencies” are really giving away to favored companies. For all we know, they have been giving away the Filipino nation’s birthright, probably the main reason why we can’t seem to achieve economic takeoff despite a favorable external economic environment.

In the last 20 years, BOI, the Philippine Economic Zone Authority and several other “investments promotion agencies” have been giving away all sorts of perks—income tax holiday; duty-free importation of machines and equipment; exemption on duties and taxes on imported spare parts; exemption from wharfage dues and export tax, duty, imposts and fees; tax exemption on breeding stocks and genetic materials; tax credits; and additional deductions from taxable income—and we can’t seem to account for their impact on the Philippine economy and our future as a nation.

Agencies like the National Economic and Development Authority, the Department of Finance, and the Department of Trade and Industry cannot account for the real contribution of these perks to economic development because they may have been designed as a vehicle for rent-seeking behavior in the bureaucracy. Amid this flurry of perks are a tangle of almost 200 other laws and executive orders giving privileges to companies to claim more fiscal perks from the country’s coffers for several other economic activities ranging from the production of steels and ships and jewelries. This confusing snarls of laws and regulations and the apparent lack of transparency with which these agencies implement them suggest that abuses like double-dipping (claiming perks for the same projects from several laws and agencies) and the brazen act of collecting perks for investment projects that were not even registered with the BOI are prevalent.

Right now, the DTI does not want to release detailed information about the issue because “they are still completing their findings.” Congress should not wait for that report before acting on behalf of the Filipino people.

Imports figures say economy is on track

Imports rose more than ten percent in January-August this year, allaying fears of a possible slowdown late this year. It’s encouraging to note that purchases of capital equipment also rose significantly at more than 8 percent. It means our business people are buying machines and equipment for their factories and offices, an indicator of business confidence. But is it enough to reverse the decline in capital formation? That's the big question that could only be answered with the release of national income accounts in the third quarter.

Notable increases in capital imports could be noticed particularly in telecommunications equipment and electrical machines, as well as aircraft, ships and boats. This means the telecom boom in this country is continuing. The drive towards the 3G is one possible factor for this trend.

Friday, October 27, 2006

It's time to move on

Now that the Supreme Court has rejected Sigaw ng Bayan’s petition for Charter change through the “people’s initiative,” let’s bury that effort deep into Hades and move on with our lives.

If there’s one major political issue that’s dividing the country and has prevented the government from focusing its energies on the Philippine economy, that’s the Cha-cha. Let’s now consign it to the dustbin of history. Let’s work together as a nation to focus on the economy where we could really make a difference in the lives of ordinary people.

Actually, the Filipino people have moved on a long time ago and focused on what really matters most—their means of living. In the 10 quarters the Philippine economy has been growing within the 5-percent to 6-percent growth rate band despite all the handicaps of having to put up with corrupt leaders and perpetually squabbling politicians. And it’s quite a broad-based effort as the farms, factories and services all contributed significantly.

Our entrepreneurs, despite all the odds, moved heaven and earth to set up as well as attract investors in call centers, shared services, software developers and electronics if only to provide job opportunities and hopes to young college graduates.

Sick and tired of negativism and continuing tales of corruption in high places, many of our countrymen, many of them women, have left the country to slave it out as domestic helpers, nurses, engineers and service workers so they could send back dollars to their families and save the country from tearing apart. The government, the State and its leaders, have failed them but those OFWs can’t afford to fail their families so they just closed their eyes and out they went to endure loneliness and hard work in foreign shores.

Now, the entrepreneurs’, the farmers’ and OFWs’ money are lifting the economy out of its boom-bust cycles, creating demand for goods and services, giving life and more profits to factories, banks, hotels and restaurants, and shopping malls. Certainly, these gains are not enough to create a million jobs and soak up joblessness, but the people have done a lot of their own to kick-start an economic revolution that may yet lift the economy into a higher growth path if only the country’s political leaders would cooperate.

Yes, in the last 10 quarters, the economy—and we call it a people’s economy because it has been moving steadfastly on autopilot —grew amid declining capital expenditures from the government. Yes, the people—the entrepreneurs, including foreign investors; the working people in offices, farms and factories; and OFWs have moved on and tried hard to do business and create jobs while bureaucrats and politicians holding the levers of power are preoccupied with nothing but their day-to-day political survival.

And yes, the people sacrificed a lot by agreeing to a higher value-added tax if only the country’s finances could rise up beyond the shortsightedness of their political “leaders.”

Now, it’s high time that our political leaders, especially those in the ruling party, perform their own “sacrifice” by reining in their irrational political exuberance and focus their energies on the economy. Right now, the Philippine economy has reached a stage where shifting to a higher growth path requires a constructive role for the State, something that it has failed to do in the last three years.

In 2001, the country’s national government deficit was equivalent to 4.1 percent of the country’s gross domestic product (GDP). By this time of the year, the government’s national deficit is down to about 2 percent of the GDP, an indication that the people have done their share of moving this country forward.

We are not saying here that we should forget all about the sins of the malefactors in this government. Certainly we still want to have real closure to the Bolante fertilizer and other scams. We are saying that the rule of law should proceed to its due course while doing away with the unnecessary political distractions that could derail the country from its path to development. Surely, the political questions will linger. But we should let the May election next year and other legal procedures available to the opposition settle those political questions.

We are not blind to the arguments for economic reforms advocated by the proponents of Cha-cha. Indeed there is a need to remove the remaining obstacles to entrepreneurship and investments in this country. The main problem that stops us from supporting this effort is its political complications. When “economic reforms” are clouded by political opportunism, such a process of change loses credibility and therefore creates uncertainty that hampers economic expansion.

Some Cha-cha proponents say we need to dance the Cha-cha now or we lose the chance forever. We share their concern for stasis, but we believe that if the economic reforms being pushed through Cha-cha are really such good ideas, they are going to have a momentum of their own. No one could stop the flow of good ideas; they are going to gain flesh, blood and passion at the right time sans the baggage of partisan political considerations.

Stability, continuity and order. That’s what the country needs now.

Tuesday, October 24, 2006

That messy MISSI!

Four months into Christmas, the average capacity utilization of selected manufacturing enterprises remained high at 80.3 percent. That's good news, an indicator that the manufacturing sector has been pretty stable. But wait a minute! Why is it stable when it's supposed to move upwards? In the last ten quarters, the manufacturing sector has been growing at 4-5 percent. That means factories should be busier. But why is not reflected in the Monthly Survey of Selected Industries (Missi)? Something must be wrong somewhere.

Another question: why is it that for the last eight months, the volume of output has been declining? Of course, the computation of the national accounts is probably based on value, and the value of output has been growing quite well. But that's not an adequate explanation. Merchandize exports have been growing briskly in the last eight months. That means there's a real expansion in factory activities! But why is it not reflected in the Missi?

It's possible that the Missi is based on an old sampling structure that no longer reflect the new dynamics of the Philippine. Or its possible that private business organizations dont just tell the truth when the NSO people came.

Monday, October 23, 2006

Third World telecom, first world charges!

WE support the efforts of the Philippine government, specifically the National Telecommunication Commission (NTC), to make the country’s telecommunications industry competitive and efficient.

That policy environment is long overdue. Had we established an open and competitive policy environment for the telecommunications sector—nay, for the entire services sector— a decade or two ago, this country could have been growing as fast as India and China by now. We have missed a beat in the ongoing Information Revolution but it’s not yet too late to catch up. The government may not have the money to “upgrade” this country into the 21st century, but it could certainly do so by ensuring a competitive environment through several measures including disincentives to predatory practices and abuses. And why not go all the way by opening everything 100 percent to foreign direct investments?

The Philippine economy, and the entire Filipino nation for that matter, is better off in a more competitive policy environment for all economic sectors, not just telecommunications. Such a policy environment assures easy entry and exit, and therefore would allow more innovative players to emerge, thus offering better and cheaper value-added services that will benefit the entire economy. Open competition ensures the economic diversity that this country needs to grow and mature as well as withstand potential shocks from an increasingly globalizing world. Besides, open competition and greater economic diversity benefits all Filipinos in terms of choices. Right now, many Filipinos go abroad the moment they have the opportunity to do so because they feel powerless vis-à-vis factors like lack of career choices, lack of clear direction for the economy, and the utter inefficiencies of structures and institutions affecting their lives that could be linked to the country’s economically restrictive policies.

Right now, the Philippines is considered the “texting capital of the world.” But that’s an ironic reputation since the Philippines right now has among the highest or the most expensive telecommunications charges in the Asia-Pacific Region. According to the latest study by the Asian Institute of Management (AIM), overseas calls to the United States now cost US$0.90 for every three minutes—yes, that’s P45 pesos per three minutes—against $0.48 in India and $0.71 in Malaysia, our closest competitors in the outsourcing business. To call the US, the Canadians ($0.48 per 3 minutes), the Irish ($.59 per three minutes), and the British ($.65 per three minutes) are charged even lower rates than us Filipinos who are dirt poor! It’s these skyrocketing telecommunications charges that are forcing us to do the finger-breaking task of encoding letters into those tiny keypads one by one so we could send important messages to our loved ones.

In this country, however, companies are making money from the sale of cellular-phone units alone, the cheapest of which could cost nearly $200. In India, the typical cellular phone handset would cost as much as US$60. In other countries like the United States, telecom companies would even give away cellular phones for free if only to get subscription. Telecommunications companies would move heaven and earth just to please their clients.

This is now the 21st century, where wealth is created through innovation as well as the creation of knowledge. Access to information, specifically the Internet, is vital to progress and development. But what we have in this country right now is the deepening of the digital divide, where the rich who are few are getting the best of the digital world while the poor could not even think beyond three square meals a day. Again, that’s because of the uncompetitive situation in this industry. Right now, according to the AIM, Filipinos also bear the highest Internet charges in the region. On a monthly basis, Filipinos pay about US$17.05 for Internet services as against $8.74 a month for Indians, $8.42 a month for the Malaysians, $10 for the Chinese, $12.71 for Canadians, and $14.95 for Americans.

For a very poor country with just over a thousand dollars of per capita income, Filipinos are paying telecom and Internet charges way above what is being paid by citizens in the First World countries, who enjoy per capita incomes ranging from 10 thousand to 30 thousand dollars! And most of us don’t even enjoy the benefits of real broadband that most of these neighboring countries have. Why should Filipinos continue to put up with these, when they certainly deserve better?

Many of us still wonder why we can’t seem to catch up with our neighbors in the Asia-Pacific Region. The major reasons for this continuing underdevelopment lie with these realities. Not only do we have the most expensive electricity, we also have the most expensive telecommunications and Internet services, thus ranking us among the most expensive places to do business.

Right now, we still attract lots of investments in cyberservices. But that’s because skilled labor here is dirt cheap. So are the prices of real- estate. But once the supply of skilled professionals and technical people tightens, wages will rise. So will real-estate prices, especially now that occupancy rates in major urban centers are approaching 100 percent. That will push up business cost in the Philippines higher than places like India, Malaysia and Vietnam. That in turn will turn away cyberindustries from the Philippines. Our skilled professionals and technical people will probably follow them through global migration should that happen. That will be the tragedy of us all.

The choices therefore are clear: reform and be competitive—or perish.

Thursday, October 19, 2006

Philippine export numbers are looking good!

The Philippine merchandize exports rose 17 percent year-on-year in January to August this year. Now, that's real good news for the Philippine economy. The reasons? Electronics exports are doing well. So are other sectors including minerals, liquified petroleum gas, transmission applications, electrical machinery, bananas, basketwares, wiring sets, copper bars and rods, and crude coconut oil. That means the growth in exports are pretty broad-based.

It appears that the main sources of growth in the Philippines have been diversifying quite fast lately. Besides merchandize exports, services exports (outsourcing) and remittances from overseas workers are contributing significantly. Nice to know things are improving this side of the Pacific.

American national security experts don't know the difference between Sunni and Shiite!

"Know thy enemy, know thyself. A hundred battles fought a hundred battles won. That’s classic Sun Tzu. Everybody who is into the war business or intelligence knows that, right? American “national security experts” who are prosecuting the war on terror therefore should know the difference between Sunni and Shiite, right? Wrong. In fact, most of them don’t know a damn thing. In his article in Washington Post, Jeff Stein lamented:

And as I quickly explain to my subjects, I’m not looking for theological explanations, just the basics: Who’s on what side today, and what does each want?

But so far, most American officials I’ve interviewed don’t have a clue. That includes not just intelligence and law enforcement officials, but also members of Congress who have important roles overseeing our spy agencies. How can they do their jobs without knowing the basics?

That answers our questions why George Bush’s “democratization” project in the Middle East is such a mess. It’s probably the same group of people who fed George Bush the term "Islamo-fascism" that proved to be an embarrassment. Condoleeza Rice and Bush later had to discontinue using the term.

“Truly, we are governed by idiots!,” cries Americablog.com.

The new refurbished Blogger is cool!

Seems like I'm back actively blogging with blogger now that it has new cool features. I've started with Blogger November 29 last year. But as I got deeply into blogging, I realized its features are inferior compared to other platforms like Wordpress. So I strayed into Wordpress and Multiply from which I developed a new online social networks. With these new features, however, I guess I'll be back. Multiply of course is a totally different experience and I'll continue posting personal stuff there. Here in Blogger, I'll continue tackling the usual "serious" stuff I've been doing since last year.

For you guys in Blogger.com, thanks a lot!

Wednesday, October 18, 2006

Christmas is in the air!

Siberian winds are blowing; Christmas is in the air.

From dusk until dawn, the air is colder and pleasant, giving me nice dreamless sleep. The shopping malls start thinking about Christmas at the start of the BER months. My own trigger is the start of the colder nights in October which usually last until January.

Oh Christmas! I wonder why I look at it now with much anticipation. I usually don’t because Christmas to me has always been about traffic congestion, parties, and food binging—which makes me even fatter than I am right now. Journalists work until the 24th of December and are back on the road by the 26th so there’s really nothing to expect in terms of a longer break. We are like those much-abused ground pounders in the armed forces.

Christmas makes life more difficult for journalists. When interviewed, sources are usually polite, nice and impertinent. They will say “C’mon, its party time, ask me that later. You’re too serious!” Or they say “Oh, I’m scheduled to attend this dinner and that party. Could we reschedule the interview after Christmas?” There goes your story.

But I’m still excited. Maybe there’s more to this one. I don’t know but I hope. Maybe that’s Christmas: hope, dreams, and expectations that the next year will turn out good and nice.

RP's fundamentals are improving but fundamental problems linger

THE “fundamentals” are definitely right when we simply look at the Philippines’ external sector. That’s what the International Monetary Fund (IMF) wanted to see and it definitely got a beautiful picture. But those are not the only numbers out there that matter, and one needs to go deep into the “internal sector” to get the larger view of the forest. The IMF saw a few robust trees that it deemed enough to pronounce the health of the whole forest stable and nice.

Definitely it is pleasing to hear the IMF finally saying something positive about the Philippines after four decades that the country has been under its tutelage. For a long time, multilateral institutions including the World Bank, International Finance Corporation, and the Asian Development Bank, have had the habit of castigating Filipinos by announcing a lower growth forecast which time and again has been proven to be too conservative (Remember then Neda chief Solita Monsod’s quarrel with a visiting IMF team, where she said one cannot attain fiscal targets “on the backs of the Filipino people”—meaning, one can only obsess with numbers up to a point that does not hurt the ordinary folk so much). The IMF “experts” criticisms are usually couched in polite language yet the message sent is clear: that the Philippines is the same old laggard that it used to be in the last 20-30 years.

Not anymore. No one talks about the “boom-bust cycle” these days. The economy has moved up within the 5-6 percent, owing to the strength of the services sector and surprising recovery in both agriculture and industry. And recent trends in the external sector, the IMF’s favorite trees, are definitely encouraging.

From January to August this year, exports grew 17 percent, owing to the strength of electronics, garments, agricultural products, and minerals. Foreign direct investments have lately breached the billion-dollar mark. That’s loose change compared to China’s 60-billion dollar FDI figure but at least, the trend has been on the way up. The dollar flows from overseas workers remain in the double-digit rate. Dollar-wielding tourists have also been on the rise, numbering more than 1.4 million in the first half of the year. Dollar reserves have reached more than 4 months’ worth or imports. And national government debt has fallen to about 2 percent of the country’s gross domestic product, way down from 5.3 percent five years ago.

These are great indicators and we are happy about them but they hardly represent a totally, healthy and stable forest. In the last several years, capital formation—data that represent changes in the capital stock (buildings, machines, inventories) and how savings is used for investments—have been in the negative. Specifically, fixed capital measuring the value of construction, durable equipment, and breeding stocks and orchard has also been in the negative.

These figures simply mean that the 5-6 percent growth was achieved through the contributions of Filipino citizens through their personal consumption (no doubt significantly financed by remittances), and trade (imports and exports) in both merchandise and services (specifically cyberservices). Yes, that’s the glowing “external sector” but it doesn’t really say much about the general strength of the Philippine economy, especially if we view the Philippine’s performance within the context of the performance of the entire Asia-Pacific Region.

Several questions arise: first, why is it that despite the better growth figures, capital formation has not been rising? Does it mean the country’s entrepreneurs are not investing? That seems to be the conclusion one gets. It means entrepreneurs are still hesitant to buy machines, upgrade their factories, and build inventories on a scale that would show up in the country’s national income accounts. This looks like they don’t have long-term confidence in the economy.

And why not, when the government itself has not been investing in the country’s future? In 2006, the government has been operating on a reenacted budget, thus preventing it from raising expenditure on crucial economic and social infrastructure. Worse, whatever little public expenditure money the government possesses has been lying idle, either because of low absorptive capacity or plain bureaucratic inertia. President Arroyo announced a massive public expenditure program in the last State of the Nation Address for the “super regions” but there seems to have been less buzz about it since then. Government, it appears, has not really moved fast enough despite the urgency of the situation. Take note how the government has become silent on the matter after the announcement.

Or maybe it’s deliberate so the government could window-dress the country’s finances and mask its under-underachievement especially in tax. Why do we say this? It’s because in the last nine months, the government has failed to meet tax collection targets, and yet comes up with a deficit figure that’s 41 percent better than program. Somehow, in order to present a very good fiscal picture to the IMF and the credit-rating agencies, the government needs to tighten on spending. This tack seems to shoot two birds with one stone, i.e., present a good picture to the IMF et al, while giving officials generous elbow room for spending towards the end of the year. Of course, it is so tempting to suspect that the government is probably building a dam of people’s money so that it could release the floodgates just in time for the election season. Talk about “fiscal consolidation”!

These are the facts the IMF has failed to see. And we are concerned that the IMF praises could even serve as an incentive for the government to do less. Now, that’s the real tragedy because it even jeopardizes the long-term prospects of the economy.

Thursday, October 12, 2006

Mixed signals on fiscal incentives

We hope that President Gloria Macapagal Arroyo (GMA) was just talking in general terms to soothe the nerves of business people who attended workshop on foreign direct investment in the Philippines organized by the American Chamber of Commerce.

The president said that “our policy is to keep and improve the incentives the Philippines offers strategic foreign and domestic investors, especially exporters. The incentives need not be fiscal. The incentives you want are the competitiveness element: the workers being paid well enough in terms of affordable food; the technology, in other words, our continuing knowledge worker richness in our economy; the infrastructure; the power; and the reduction in the red tape. “

And on fiscal incentives she said: “let us assure you too that the Philippines will not become less competitive in the fiscal incentives we offer our foreign and domestic investors. I know some of your worries that's why I want to assure you that we will not support proposals that have that effect of reducing competitiveness.”

Anybody who follows the debate on the fiscal rationalization bill now being discussed in the Senate would find those statements confusing. On one hand, she was saying that competitiveness ultimately depends on a much broader range of factors like the state of infrastructure, overall policy environment, among others. This has been the argument by the economists who think it’s high time we junk the current fiscal incentives system that has been causing a lot of hemorrhage in the country’s revenue collection system. Each year, based on data from the Department of Finance, the country has been foregoing collection of at least P300 billion a significant part of which are probably redundant and unnecessary. Had the country been able to collect at least half of that, so the argument goes, we could have accumulated a significant amount of money to fund the building of more roads, bridges, and other important infrastructure. Doing this would mean that we achieve “fiscal consolidation,” obtain better sovereign ratings that would guarantee easier and cheaper access to global capital for both the public and private business organizations.

But on the other hand, she seems to be saying she is going to junk the bill being discussed at the Senate ways and means committee, one major proposal of which, is the removal of income tax holidays granted to firms registered with the Board of Investments, to be replaced with a uniform 15 tax percent rate. Some companies and business organizations have been worried that the removal of their income tax holidays would undermine their competitiveness. If President Arroyo was actually to talking to this crowd, then certainly she is telling Senate that their deliberations are going nowhere as she is bent on maintaining the status despite here earlier commitment to reform the country’s fiscal incentive system.

But then again, we don’t really know. She may have been saying that broader economy-wide incentives are in the offing. For instance, what prevents the country from simplifying the incentives regime by wholesale reduction of corporate income tax from the current 36 percent to say 15 percent a la Hongkong and Ireland? Certainly, that will be more attractive to investors as they no longer have to see the face of bureaucrats when setting up their operations here. That policy option shoots several birds in one stone: you address red tape (you could even abolish many of these agencies including the BOI), ensure transparency, and speeds up the process of setting up business.

But who knows? So until this time, the uncertainty continues. And it’s sending a mixed signal to the Senate ways and means committee that is currently crafting the fiscal rationalizations bill. When legislators started discussing the fiscal incentives rationalizations bill, the mood from Malacañang has been towards improving the country’s finances. Now, Malacañang is singing a confusing tune, something that will confuse the investor community even more. It’s this uncertainty that actually drives away foreign investors.

Is there a way out? Joachim von Amsberg, country director of the World Bank in the Philippines, has a concrete set of solutions during that worshop. Allow us to site a few:

First, ensure macroeconomic stability and fiscal sustainability (efficient collection of taxes). Second, continue deregulation in the economy (which could mean no more oligopoly in shipping and port operations). Third, move away from sector or firm specific to economy wide deregulation and incentives (read: why not provide incentives for everybody through a lower corporate income tax across the board?). Fourth, uphold the sanctity of contracts (a contract is a contract is a contract!). Fifth, reduce cost of doing business (no red tape, speed up court processes, no graft). Sixth, ensure open and competitive bidding (no under the table deals). And seventh, further liberalize foreign entry into the financial services sector (read an end to the banking oligopoly).

If we could achieve most of these recommendations, we may realize we may not even need “fiscal incentives.”

Monday, October 09, 2006

City in a cage

WHAT is Bayani Fernando trying to prove? That Filipinos are animals that need to be controlled, manipulated through cages, bullying cops and physical barriers?
At the rate he is erecting visually intrusive iron cages in every corner of the metropolis, we will wake up one day to find our cities destroyed and freedom of movement curbed liked chicken trapped in a wire.

When President Arroyo appointed Fernando chairman of the Metropolitan Manila Development Authority (MMDA) in 2001, many residents hoped he could replicate, albeit on limited basis, what he has achieved in Marikina. Until now, Marikina is tidy, orderly and well-managed, proving to the world that Filipinos could actually clean up their surroundings, provided they elect leaders with common sense and with the will to implement zoning ordinances, rules and regulations. It ranks among those well-governed places like Puerto Princesa and Naga, cities smart enough to elect innovative and effective leaders.

When Fernando started cleaning up sidewalks by removing physical barriers to human traffic we applauded him. Here was a guy who means business, who doesn’t care about being unpopular if only to bring comfort to pedestrians.

We supported him when he started going against those grimy, topless drunks drifting around, vexing passersby. And, even if it looked so much like a publicity stunt, companies supported him by donating deodorants in his efforts to rid the streets of sweaty, stinking sando-wearing jeepney drivers. Surely, we need cleanliness in the streets and the drivers’ armpits are the most strategic places to start if we have to bring Metro Manila into the 21st century.

In an urban setting people should respect their fellowmen by behaving accordingly. That’s the essence of urbanidad (urbanism), the catchphrase with which Fernando justifies his actions. In simpler terms, urbanism means people should be taught the sophistication needed to live in crowded urban areas. It means people should not litter, not urinate against the wall, use the traffic lights; pedestrians should cross only on pedestrian lanes, should not engage in long, loud karaoke sessions in the neighborhood, or let their dogs relieve themselves on sidewalks. Most important, drivers should follow traffic laws. In all this, public education would play a big role.
Under Fernando, we had higher expectations that—together with Manila’s mayors and barangay chairmen—he would embark on a serious campaign to promote this behavior among Metro Manilans. He had the support of well- meaning citizens and the corporate world to catalyze an Urban Revolution.

We knew he did not have the charm of a Juan Flavier when he was at the Department of Health, but at least we expected even a fraction of Flavier’s ability to get things done without bullying people. Who can argue that Filipinos are among the most hard-headed people, and our drivers are always held up as models of road barbarism? But Flavier proved that even a hard-headed populace, if educated and motivated enough, could be prodded to act for its own sake. Defying skepticism, he organized the world’s first multivaccine national immunization campaign, and achieved universal coverage for it, drawing praise from the UN no less. Flavier succeeded even with modest resources because he multiplied his charm—he got private firms and other state agencies to help; got the military and communist rebels to honor a nationwide cease-fire just to let health workers reach remote villages; and got mass media to give free services and air time.
Since Fernando was an organization man and seemed to have the right vision, people reposed hope in him as they did with Flavier. Instead, he embarked on inane projects that distracted people from their noble purpose: pink urinals, the wet blankets to force people into using the sidewalks, U-turn slots, and lately, the pink cages to herd weary commuters into buses. The pink urinals are ugly and stink, the wet blankets downright fascistic, and the cages visually intrusive and mean—all of them don’t achieve the desired results.

Citizens thought Fernando’s pink urinals were just temporary, to be replaced later by better comfort rooms, and complimented by a massive awareness program. It turned out later the pink urinals are the end-all and the be-all—institutionalizing an inappropriate behavior that should have no place in an urban context. If he wanted to eliminate pissing against the wall, all he had to do was look at Manila Mayor Lito Atienza who eliminated the pink urinals and installed clean comfort rooms in the right places in Manila.

Metro Manila is going against the trend of modern urban traffic management. Instead of computerizing the traffic system, and educating traffic enforcers and pedestrians, Fernando had a simple solution: the U-turn slot. Without consulting traffic planners, he erected them all over the metropolis, causing traffic chokepoints at strategic areas. Traffic engineers say that installing a U-turn slot creates more traffic-flow conflict and therefore prone to traffic accidents.
But the nastiest of them all are really the pink cages. You could see them quickly expanding all around Metro Manila now, especially in central places like Quezon Avenue and Edsa and Baclaran. Garish and ugly, these cages restrict a pedestrian’s movements, causing inconvenience among people at peak hours. A commuter who disembarks on Quezon Avenue—especially the MRT station—during rains will have to suffer long walks through the cages if only to get a ride. The junction at the corner of Edsa-Quezon Avenue itself, a public space, is now an ugly parking garage for taxis and jeepneys peddling their services to passengers who walk along the narrow, caged and crowded pathways.

Why do they need the cage? Because the U-turn slot at the intersection of Quezon Avenue and Edsa has become a chokepoint, so they’d rather control people if they can’t control the vehicles. So here is a case of one silly measure, a U-turn slot, being compounded by another silly one like the cage. We are not even talking here of aesthetics, which those pink cages have totally destroyed. Come to think of it, Binay’s Makati also has fences for traffic control, but they are nowhere near as repulsive as the pink chicken cages at Edsa. Beyond aesthetics and inconvenience, there’s also safety: not a few people complain that the “cages” make them easy prey for robbers, who can easily stick a knife into them in certain dark, narrow parts of the cages.

These cages signal a certain mean-spiritedness, or a complete insensitivity to those who can’t afford cars. Chairman Fernando seems to have a dim view of humanity; he looks at ordinary people as creatures who need to be controlled through physical barriers and violence at all times, when in truth there are ways by which he could get them to stop jaywalking, if that’s his purpose.

Monday, October 02, 2006

To the future through the cities from the farms

WE totally agree with the National Economic and Development Authority (Neda) that the country’s future depends on its urban areas. But we would like to add a little phrase to that line—only if the cities articulate well with the countryside.

Only if the farms are thoughtfully integrated into a well-defined hierarchy of urban systems that nurtures, instead of suppresses, the hinterlands’ development potentials. And only if the policy environment supports that kind of a growth strategy through infrastructure development and a competitive, if not totally deregulated, transport systems. Sad to say, we don’t have such right now.

Definitely, if we look at history, the way to the future is the journey to the cities. There is no escaping that fact. As the economy transforms from agriculture to industry and ultimately services, there’s no denying that truism that people will have to move from the countryside to the cities to take advantage of economic opportunities there as well as become catalysts of that transformation. A lot of activities that unleash economic development and progress will never be viable without the economies of scale that urbanization provides.

That’s the theory, of course, and it’s quite simple and neat as any practitioners of the dismal science would tell us. It’s as simple and neat as any country in the West has experienced. In the context of the developing world, however, the story is full of twists and turns and its details don’t normally fit in the econometric models of economists nurtured from the books of Adam Smith and Milton Friedman. Colonialism came and urbanization transmogrified as a structure to squeeze off surplus from the plantations, forests, and mines in the wilderness and bowels of the “third world,” and we never seemed to have totally got over it despite efforts to reverse the trend.

Wonder why cities like Davao and Cagayan de Oro do not seem to interact well with the interiors of Mindanao? It’s because Davao and the like were designed primarily as port cities to facilitate the flow of timber, gold, silver, pineapples, bananas and fishes from the inner core of Mindanao straight to Manila then Japan, US, and Europe. In Negros, the infrastructure system seems to reflect the same need to speed up sugar exports at the expense of the island’s need for diversification. The same trend could be observed elsewhere, a phenomenon called rural-urban dualism that explains much about the underdevelopment of rest of the country.

We are not against trade of these resource-based products per se. They are very important components of the Philippine economy. But it must be stressed that a well-integrated network of settlements and production areas connected by an efficient network of infrastructure would go a long way in diversifying the economy and spreading the benefits of trade and globalization to broader segments of society.

Slowly, government planners have come to realize this and are trying to undo the bad legacies of the past, but these efforts have always been a little too late.

Much of the solution is related to infrastructure development. None has been done on this aspect so far. In an archipelagic country such as ours, experts have been stressing the need for comprehensive multimodal transport network that would economically link production areas with the country’s urban systems. Yet the government’s record on this has been spotty, nothwithstanding its claim about the “nautical highway.” The government has been so lousy at collecting taxes that it has been convenient for economic planners to skip on economic infrastructure spending, if only to achieve fiscal consolidation.

The other task is simply rewriting the rules of the game to attract more players and put more competitive pressure on the country’s producers and service providers. You don’t expect banks, shipping companies, telecommunications providers to provide top-of-the-line services and technologies if they are complacent in their oligopolistic perches. The best thing the government could do is remove the remaining restrictions on full foreign participation. Again, the government has been reluctant to do this for fear of alienating the vested interests in these sectors. The Philippines has actually pioneered the policy of attracting private sector money to fund infrastructure development but corruption and scandals, the prototypical example of which is Piatco/Naia Terminal III, have practically killed that option.

This continuing failure to undertake these twin measures accounts for the messy rural-urban transition in the Philippines. In the Dismal Science’s neat theory on structural change, the transfer of people from the farms to the cities is always smooth and seamless. People from the farms, made redundant by technological innovation (e.g. farm mechanization, use of better crop science) got jobs in the ever-growing factories and service offices. In the Philipines, low farm productivity—again because of factors like lack of infrastructure and inadequate market information—are driving farm people to the cities, only for them to end up in the slums and the informal sector, thus stretching the cities’ economic and social services.

Economic opportunities in the factories and offices have been growing quite well—thanks to the boom in electronics, call centers, and other service-oriented activities— but they are not growing fast enough to absorb those who come from rural areas in droves for the same reason that we didn’t set the policy environment right. That explains the pervasive joblessness despite decent economic growth.

Yes, the way to the future is through the cities. Yet we will never get there for as long as we continue to ignore those who live in the farms.

Tuesday, September 26, 2006

Philippine outsourcing is undergoing transformation!


CHANGING BPO LANDSCAPE
CALL CENTERS ARE STILL A HOT SOURCE FOR LOCAL JOBS
BUT OTHER BPO SERVICES ARE ON THE RISE

By David Llorito, Debbie Pepito & Louise Francisco
Research Staff, BusinessMirror

The country’s cyberservices industry appears to be undergoing a transformation. According to BusinessMirror’s Job Ad Index in August, not only is the much-ballyhooed sector getting bigger, it is also expanding into other business activities that may soon blur the difference among the different types of outsourcing services.

For August, BusinessMirror’s Jobs Ads Index rose 18 percentage points from its base in June, driven largely by the continuing demand for workers in cyberservices, construction and engineering, manufacturing, and hotels, restaurants and resorts. For the month, total job ads reached 31,177, about 30 percent of which came from the cyberservices sector. In June, the base on which the index is computed, total job ads reached only 26,216, yet even then cyberservices already accounted for a third of the want ads.

Since May, the research staff of the BusinessMirror has been monitoring job advertisements in the Philippines as a way to determine labor demand, business confidence and the performance of the country’s economy in general. Every day, the research staff has been tallying job-ad placements in the Manila Bulletin, the Philippine Daily Inquirer and the Philippine Star, as well as those posted on Internet job sites jobstreet.com.ph, jobsdb.net and bestjobs.ph, classifying the ads by industry and occupation.

This research effort is inspired by the Help Wanted Index developed by the Conference Board, a New York-based nonprofit organization that “disseminates knowledge about management and the marketplace to help businesses strengthen their performance and better serve society.”

Outsourcing transformation
Since 2003, prospects of the cyberservices industry have been constantly reported as being hampered by a skills crunch. Yet results of the Job Ads Index in the last three months continue to buck this observation. In August, for instance, jobs advertisements posted by the sector grew 54 percent from its base in June, an indication of its continuing robustness.

For one, the volume of business at the country’s call centers is constantly expanding. Dell Inc., the American computer manufacturer that operates a call center in Pasay City, for instance, continues to hire call-center agents as it targets to have a 1,400-man labor pool. Currently, it employs 900 call-center agents. Next year, it is set to open another call-center operation to provide additional technical support for US consumers. The new site is expected to take its first customer calls in February 2007. Staffing plans for the new location are already being finalized.

“Our Pasay City team has done an excellent job in answering customer questions and solving their issues, delivering Dell’s outstanding customer experience that comes with the direct relationship between us and our customers. That is a major factor in our decision to expand our investment in the country,” said Richard Hunter, Dell’s vice president for Americas customer experience and support.

Added country manager Michael Garrison: “We continue to exceed growth plans and are focused on improving the customer experience. We need experienced problem solvers who can simplify and resolve increasingly complex technical and customer-care challenges for home consumers.”

Besides Dell, other heavy job advertisers in the cyberservices sector are Ab Systems, Teletech and Advanced Contact Solutions.

But the sector isn’t just about call centers these days, as there is a growing trend toward other outsourcing activities. Although more than half (52 percent) of the 9,192 job ads posted by the cyberservices sector in August were for call centers, hiring activity was also robust in software development and other IT-enabled services (40 percent) and back-office processing (5 percent). The remaining 5 percent of cyberservices job ads were for animation, medical transcription, and engineering design.

And as the scope of services expands, pretty soon it may not be that easy to classify companies as purely call centers. Accenture, for example, which primarily does software development and back-office work, recently opened its own call center, while call centers like People Support have ventured into medical transcription. Client Logic is also venturing into medical transcription.

“I think there will be a convergence of activities,” observes Frank Holz, chief executive of consultancy firm Outsource2Philippines. “A lot of these guys are doing call-center work but they’re also doing BPO [back-office] work for the same client. So on one hand, you’re doing the back-office accounting or you’re doing an HR function. Pretend that somebody has a question about that, they can call in and you got the call-center activity related to that also.”

Holz predicts that although call centers will continue to expand, these companies will eventually venture into other types of BPO work. “The future isn’t as bright [for call centers] as it is for the other types of activities. You might find some arguments on that but that’s how I see it. If you have a certified public accountant doing the books for a company, that’s worth a lot more than a call-center person answering requests for information,” he said.

Perhaps that’s why call centers are now exploring markets other than the English-speaking world. For instance, Link2Support in Eastwood City, Libis, has been posting job advertisements for Korean technical support representatives. The company already has 10 Korean call-center staff.

“The account itself services mostly English-speaking countries but we do have customers in Thailand, Indonesia and Korea, so we thought putting agents who speak other languages was a good idea,” said Raymond Deato, Link2Support’s human-resource specialist for foreign-language accounts. “Koreans, for example, do not speak English that well, so they would really be more comfortable speaking to a technical support representative who can speak Korean.

“It’s just harder for us to recruit because we’re a technical support account, so we have to consider an applicant’s technical background,” Deato added. “The others are mostly customer-care accounts, so kahit ano’ng course pwede dun. But we do have Spanish-speaking Filipino agents. Marami naman kasi ang mga mestizo dito. It’s just for the Thai, Indonesian and Korean accounts that we have foreigners.”

Convergys, one of the biggest call centers in the country and a Fortune 500 company, has also been seeking multilingual customer-care representatives, particularly those who can speak Mandarin, Fookien and Cantonese. Emerson, an engineering design-outsourcing firm, was also looking for customer-services associates who are fluent in German, French, Italian and Mandarin for Sykes, Emerson’s call-center partner.

There are also those like Prime@ Technology Specialists Inc. that are seeking helpdesk analysts who can converse in Nihonggo and English, while Nihon Software Outsourcing Vision Inc. is in the market for Nihonggo-speaking finance and administrative assistants.

BPO work has become so popular that several entrepreneurs have ventured into setting up their own call centers out of their homes such as Aicom Solutions (telemarketing), Get-A-Filipino (inbound and outbound calls, data processing and medical transcription), Freedom Telework (back office), Agi (Internet content provider) and Jump2Top (Web development, online marketing).

“We have an office coming up in Ortigas area…but the process is taking time and we need to expand quickly, so we thought that home-based operations would be great for our company,” said Roque Lim, sales and marketing assistant of Aicom Solutions. “We did corrective actions first and tried home-based operations and it worked!”

Lim stressed that this is just temporary but he obviously enjoys the convenience of the present setup.

“It’s so convenient, comfortable and flexible…. I can work in pajamas,” said Lim. “At the same time, you don’t have to have the hassle of traveling, no transportation cost. When you work in call centers, there’s a graveyard shift, and when you go out, it’s kind of dangerous. Working at home, you may feel uncomfortable working graveyard shift but you are safe.”

Factories and hotels
Apart from cyberservices, hiring in the construction and engineering sector also continues to be strong with job placements totaling 5,125 in August, a 22-percent jump from its base in June. As in the last three months, however, the bulk of these jobs—85 percent—are overseas, mostly in the petroleum industry in the Middle East and Nigeria—no doubt an effect of oil money being funneled back into oil and gas exploration, as well as modernization activities by the Gulf states.

The manufacturing sector also continues its hiring binge, with 3,037 job-placement ads in August, an increase of 22 percent from its base in June. Major advertisers include companies in food, furniture and fixtures, printing and publishing, chemical and chemical products, and metals. About 20 percent of the total manufacturing jobs are for overseas positions. In fact, most of the job placements in several industries such as rubber products, petroleum and coal, and nonmetallic mineral products are for abroad.

Business at hotels, restaurants and resorts seem to be doing well, too, given that the job ads in the hospitality industry rose 38 percent in August from its base in June. The continuing rise in visitor arrivals and the ripple effect generated by the outsourcing industry are among the main factors cited by the hospitality industry. The Hyatt group, for instance, is on the hunt for a banquet manager, a restaurant manager, a chef de partie, as well as engineers and accountants.

“This is more in response to the general growth in business demands,” explained Eugene Tamesis, director for marketing at the fairly new Hyatt Hotel and Casino Manila. “The manning levels when we started hotel operations in 2004 have grown in line with the demands of the business operations. Now with a fully operating hotel, the manning levels also have to be in accordance with the level of operations in our rooms, food and beverage and other operations.”

Tamesis said Hyatt’s occupancy has been rising since it opened two years ago. He said the hotel’s occupancy was at 51 percent at the end of 2005 and is expecting to increase to 65 percent by the end of this year.

“Our hotel has the highest growth percentage in the industry,” he boasted. “Our figures in 2005 were quite modest compared to the others but this year, we are already performing at the same level as our more established competitors.”

Hotels in the business districts of Makati and Ortigas are enjoying close to 90 percent occupancy, owing to the burgeoning outsourcing industry, sources said. Numerous executives from global outsourcing companies are coming to the Philippines to check on their operations, as well as oversee their training programs, thus boosting hotel business.

“Unfortunately, most of the BPO offices are located in Makati and the Ortigas areas,” conceded Hyatt’s Tamesis. “Therefore, growth from this segment is not expected to be as significant in the Manila Bay area, where none of these types of offices are located. However, we do have bookings from the BPO industry from our ‘Gold Passport’ members, Hyatt’s frequent-guest program, where they accumulate points from the number of stays they make in different Hyatt hotels all over the world. But the numbers are not as significant as compared to our traditional supportive industries belonging to shipping and manpower, embassy, government, pharmaceutical and gaming.”

As in the last three months, the global job market continues to weigh on the results of the Job Ads Index. Overall, a third of the job ads were for overseas. This pattern has been consistent in the last three months.

Besides construction and engineering, more than half of the jobs advertised for sectors like health and social work, nonmetallic mineral products, water transport, air transport were for overseas placements.

Nevertheless, ads for local placements are also on the rise. This largely observed in sectors such as agriculture (154 percent), mining and quarrying (51 percent), games and leisure (23 percent), media and entertainment (87 percent), and advertising and promotions (131 percent).

Even the real-estate sector is also enjoying growing confidence as it posted a 40-percent rise.

“There’s really a continuing recovery in construction and real estate in the last three years,” said Mark Taylor, operations officer of Sterling Construction and Development Corp., which produces prefabricated building materials. “In terms of revenue, we expect to grow 100 percent this year.”

Sunday, September 24, 2006

Philippines: from coco chips to microchips

On July 27, Paul Otellini, president and CEO of Intel unveiled to the world its latest and advanced microprocessor, the Intel Core 2 Duo and Intel Core 2 Extreme, packing 291 million transistors yet consuming 40 percent less power. This microprocessor enables computer users to perform several tasks faster, such as writing emails while downloading videos or music and scanning for viruses. What he didn’t tell is that a significant volume of these new microprocessors are assembled, tested, packaged and shipped from the Philippines.

Yes, Filipinos engineers and workers are capable of doing this high-tech stuff.

And more. Each year, Filipino workers and engineers produce 72 million magnetic heads, 36 million, 30 digital signal displays responsible for processing all the calls for mobile phones, 11 million liquid crystal displays, and 11 million optical disk drives. The electronics industry supplies 10 percent of the world’s semiconductor manufacturing business, 50 percent of the world’s production of 2.5 inch hard disk drive, and 10 percent of the world’s production of 3.5 inch hard disk drive. One hundred percent of the brain of cellular phones, of Nokia phones, is done here in the Philippines by Texas Instruments.

Why are we citing these statistical information? It’s to remind us that, despite of the usual political circuses performed by politicians, the Philippines is no longer what it used to be. It has changed a lot and for good. And certain, the country’s electronics industry, together with other globalized sector of the economy, is part of that changing landscape that we Filipinos should be proud of despite the country’s rambunctious politics.

In 1975, about 75 percent of the country’s exports are agriculture-based; these days, 66 percent are composed mostly of electronics. We have gone a long way from selling coconut chips to exporting microchips. This is not to disparage the farms, for its still a very important component of the economy and it pays to nurture them to ensure a broad-based growth. What we are saying here is that the Philippines has diversified a lot. It’s something that we need to encourage even more. Greater diversity means greater growth opportunities.

The industry now exports US$27 billion worth of electronics, mostly components and devices, electronic data processing, consumer electronics, automotive electronics, communication and radar, office equipment, telecommunications, control and instrumentation, and medical and industrial instrumentation.

Eight of the world’s top chipmakers (Texas Instruments, Intel, Philipps, Fairchild, Analog, Sanyo, On Semi and Rohm) and four of the world’s largest producers of hard disk drives (Hitachi, Toshiba, Fujitsu, and NEC) are in the Philippines. Mitsumi—probably the biggest employer next only to the government with its 17,000 workers—manufactures computer peripherals like CR-R and CD-RW. And equally big firms like Amkor, Epson, and Lexmark are here producing integrated circuits, terminal printers, and printheads.

Sure, the industry is still dominated by the Japanese and American investors but Filipino-owned companies are starting to get into the picture. Currently, there are 883 firms doing electronics, 247 of which are locally owned, producing lots of products including time recorders, power supplies, electronic ballasts, global positioning system tracking devices, among others. Firms like Integrated Microelectronics, Ionics, PSI Technologies, and Fastech are Filipino-owned.

Of course, critics have been saying that electronics “don’t have much linkages” with the rest of the Philippine economy. They say that most of the components or inputs of these companies are imported. But these criticisms miss the whole picture. The industry directly hires 400,000 people, provides business opportunities and generate jobs in other sectors like logistics, software development, banks, transportation, food, and beverages. And it provides the much needed diversity that the country needs to grow.

And there’s enough elbow room to grow. Right now, the Philippines actually has a budding silicon design and development industry. Companies like Intel, Rohm, Sanyo, Easix and Bitmicro are into integrated circuit design; Texas Intruments and Fairchild are into integrated circuits packaging and design; Lexmark, Easiz, and Blue Chip are into module and product design; and firms like Canon IT and Tsukiden are into firmware. The country’s test and packaging design capability for microprocessors, digital signal displays, and logic devices has also been strong. And there’s a growing base of suppliers for hard disk drives.

One might probably wonder how the Philippines succeeded as an electronics exporter. A state from one electronics industry executive should provide the explanation: “The Philippines, compared to its neighbors, doesn’t have good infrastructure. It doesn’t have good governance. But it has the best people.”

Which brings us to the main point: there’s nothing wrong with the people. There’s nothing wrong with their entrepreneurial zeal and willingness to work hard. The problem is with governance. If the country’s political leaders could do something about it, the Philippines could achieve more.