Sunday, March 11, 2007

Announcing the Spring 2007 Jefferson Fellows!

Speaking about peaks of human experiences. Yes, friends I was chosen as one of the participants of the Spring 2007 Jefferson Fellowship by the East West Center, University of Hawaii. We will be spending a week at the East-West Center in Hawaii, then another week at the Silicon Valley after which we will fly to China (Shanghai and Beijing) and India (Bangalore and Chennai). All the participants of that program are listed alphabetically below.
The Jefferson Fellows

Spring 2007
April 29–May 26

Norman Bell
Editor, Silicon Valley/San Jose Business Journal
San Jose, California, USA

Norman Bell is editor of the Silicon Valley/San Jose Business Journal, a weekly newspaper serving the business community in and around America’s 10th largest city. The newspaper, read by decision makers in Silicon Valley, has a news staff of 14 and a circulation of about 12,000.

Prior to joining the Business Journal in 2004, Mr. Bell had a lengthy career in managing daily newspapers, serving as the top editor at the News-Tribune in Tacoma, WA, (1986–91) and the Trentonian in Trenton, NJ, (1999) and as managing editor of the Albuquerque Tribune (1981–85) and the five-paper ANG group based in Oakland, CA, (2000–2004). He also has served as assistant managing editor at the Press-Enterprise in Riverside, CA, and Citizen-Journal in Columbus, Ohio, and metro editor at the Detroit News. For three years (1992–94), he taught journalism as the McMahan Centennial Professor of News Communication at the University of Oklahoma.

His newspapers have won a variety of awards including Casey medals, Associated Press Managing Editors public service honors and a James Madison award from SPJ for efforts on behalf of open records. A project of his design on euthanasia legislation was a Pulitzer finalist. He served two terms as president of the New Mexico Associated Press Managing Editors group.

Mr. Bell holds a master’s degree in American studies from Union University in Schenectady, NY, and a bachelor of commerce degree from McGill University in Montreal, Quebec, Canada. He also has attended professional programs at the American Press Institute and the Poynter Institute.

Chen Pi-Fen
Senior Reporter, Commercial Times
Taipei, Taiwan

Chen Pi-Fen, also known as Cristina, has been working as a journalist with the Commercial Times for fourteen years. The Commercial Times Co., Ltd., established in 1978, is a major member of the China Times Inc., Ltd., one of the largest domestic news groups in Taiwan. The Commercial Times is a Chinese language business daily widely read and respected by Taiwan’s investors and entrepreneurs as a professional source of financial news and market analysis.

Starting as a general reporter, Ms. Chen quickly worked her way up to become a first tier reporter and team leader in daily news. She currently serves as Section Convener of the Banking and Finance News Department and coordinator in different sections with the editorial desk. She has covered economic issues and events throughout Asia and continues to observe macroeconomic change, technology development, industry supply chains, government policies, and the Asian regional market.

She won the Pan-Asian Journalism Award of Citibank in 1993 for her story “The Greater China Policy from Multinational Corporations,” and has secured interviews with political and economic leaders such as Malaysian Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad and more than twenty winners of the Nobel Prize in Economics.

Ms. Chen also contributes to academic research as a Ph.D student in the College of International Studies in Tamkang University in Taiwan and as a research partner in the Taiwan Institute of Economic Research. She holds a master’s degree in economic society and media from Tamkang University, and participated in a journalism course at Columbia University in the United States in 1993.


Emma Connors
Senior Information Technology Writer, Australian Financial Review
Sydney, Australia

Emma Connors is the senior information technology (IT) writer at the Australian Financial Review (AFR), a business daily, owned by Fairfax Media covering corporate, economic and government news. Ms. Connors writes for the daily news pages and contributes features to the weekend edition. The AFR also publishes two monthly magazines and Ms. Connors usually juggles contributions to those publications with news writing.

Ms. Connors has been at the newspaper for almost 10 years. Before she joined the paper, she was editor of a monthly magazine, MIS Australia. Early in her career, she spent a couple of years working in London on trade publications and worked for a wine magazine in Sydney.

Last year Ms. Connors shared the Sun Microsystems features prize for IT Journalism. In 1999 she won the Eureka Prize for print journalism, for a feature story she wrote on how people who have grown up with computers think differently from those who have not. The Eureka prizes are prestigious among the science and engineering community in Australia.

Ms. Connors has a bachelor of arts in print journalism from Charles Sturt University.


Maria Henson
Deputy Editorial Page Editor, The Sacramento Bee
Sacramento, California

Maria Henson is the deputy editorial page editor for The Sacramento Bee, based in California’s capital city. She is the number two editor in the editorial department, overseeing the editorial writers, the editorial cartoonist, the public affairs columnist, the op-ed page, letters to the editor and the Sunday Forum section. One of the state’s largest metropolitan newspapers, The Sacramento Bee is prominent in its coverage of politics and state government. The newspaper’s daily circulation is 278,000 and on Sunday 330,000.

Ms. Henson came to The Sacramento Bee in June 2004 from her job as assistant managing editor for enterprise at the Austin American-Statesman in Texas, where she directed investigative and explanatory projects, headed the newsroom training efforts and oversaw the Sunday paper. She has worked as a writer at newspapers in Arkansas, Florida, Kentucky and North Carolina and has served as the Arkansas Gazette’s Washington correspondent covering Congress and federal agencies. In 2000, she went to Amherst, Mass., for one week to teach Indonesian journalists and, in 2001, traveled to Indonesia to continue the training for two weeks. Having covered Bill Clinton when he was Arkansas governor, Ms. Henson accepted an invitation in 1993 to speak in Athens, Greece, about the 1992 U.S. presidential election to European political consultants. The next year, she was a featured speaker at Taegu University in South Korea discussing U.S. press issues.

She has won a range of local, state and national journalism awards during her career. In 1992, she won the Pulitzer Prize for editorial writing for a series about how the justice system in Kentucky failed battered women and their children. Her series led the state legislature to pass every piece of reform legislation proposed to address domestic violence that year. In 1993-94 she was a Nieman Fellow at Harvard University. In 2005, the series she edited about Yosemite National Park in California won the Pulitzer Prize for editorial writing. She has been a Pulitzer Prize juror for four terms and has served on the selection committee for Nieman Fellows. Her hope is one day to publish a children’s story she wrote that was inspired by a news account after the 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami.

Ms. Henson received her bachelor’s degree in English with a minor in art history from Wake Forest University in Winston-Salem, North Carolina, in 1982.


Lee Jeahun
Staff Writer, Online News Department, The Kukmin Daily
Seoul, Korea

Lee Jeahun is a staff writer covering economic and political issues for the online news department of The Kukmin Daily. In addition to his economic and political coverage, he posts newsflash reports based on the reports of other staff writers on the Kukmin Daily website. Founded in 1988 by Yoido Full Gospel Church, The Kukmin Daily is published from Monday through Saturday. With around two hundred staff writers, The Kukmin Daily, based in Seoul, covers everything from international and domestic news to features and styles, and uniquely, includes a religious section. The paper takes the U.S.-based Christian Science Monitor as its role model.

Mr. Lee joined the online news team in April 2006. The online news department was set up in April 2004 and provides news content for The Kukmin Daily multimedia website (www.kukinews.com). Prior to this, he worked with the political news and sports departments. While with the political news team, Mr. Lee covered the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade and Ministry of Unification. He accompanied then Minister Chung Dongyoung (September 2005) to Pyongyang, North Korea to cover the 16th South-North Korea Ministerial-level Talks. In 2001, he was sent to the Pakistan-Afghanistan border city of Peshawar to cover the U.S. war on terrorism. He wrote a story about the death of fellow journalist, Aziz Haidari, a Reuter’s photographer who was shot to death by assumed Taliban insurgents.

In 2006 and 2001, Mr. Lee was awarded an in-company “exclusive report prize” for his coverage. In 2001, he was invited to Taipei by the Taipei Mission in Korea to learn more about and discuss cross-strait relations.
Mr. Lee graduated from Korea University in 1998 and holds a B.A. in Chinese language and literature. Mr. Lee maintains a strong interest in Chinese studies and the Sino-U.S. relationship. From 1994 to 1995 he took a four month language course at Beijing International Studies University and traveled extensively in China.


Liu Kunzhe
Reporter for International Desk, China Youth Daily
Beijing, China

Liu Kunzhe is a reporter for the international news desk of China Youth Daily. She is responsible for reporting diplomatic and foreign affairs, but has a strong personal interest in hi-tech innovation and climate change. China Youth Daily is one of the most influential newspapers in China, with a broad readership among the young educated urban middle class in the country. The newspaper’s daily circulation is approximately 500,000 copies, and it ranks number two among China’s national daily newspapers.

Ms. Liu came to China Youth Daily (CYD) in July 2001 after graduating from the Beijing Broadcasting Institute. Apart from being a professional reporter and editor at CYD, she also has been an intern-correspondent in the Berlin office of the Financial Times Deutschland from May to July 2006, and an intern-editor for the new program of China Central TV from January to April 2001.

Ms. Liu has won numerous awards. These include: Asia-Pacific Fellowship 2006, organized by the International Journalists’ Program of Germany; 14th China Journalism Prize (two prizes respectively in Newspaper Unit and in News Editing Unit); “Monthly Best Article Prize” from CYD for her interview with Mr. Romano Prodi, the President of the European Commission of EU; “Monthly Best Article Prize” from CYD for her serial reports on “the 2003 Conference of the Third World Academy of Science” which also won high acclaim from Lu Yongxiang, the President of the China Academy of Science.

She received her master’s degree in mass communication and international relations from the Beijing Broadcasting Institute (2001) and her bachelor’s degree in foreign affairs management from Qingdao University (1998). In addition, she received a certificate in environmental reporting from the International Institute for Journalism, Berlin, Germany (2004).

David L. Llorito
Research Head, BusinessMirror
Manila, Philippines

David Llorito has worked for almost two decades in socioeconomic research; economic and business journalism; communications/information dissemination; social assessment; and policy analysis and advocacy in agricultural, environmental, and urban policy issues. Mr. Llorito assumed his post as head of the research section of the Philippine Business Daily Mirror Publishing, Inc. in October 2005. He supervises the firm’s daily research operations, writes editorials and features, and prepares special reports on trends in the Philippine political economy for the company’s daily business newspaper called BusinessMirror. He also writes for Asia Times, an online magazine based in Hong Kong, on economic issues including business process outsourcing, mining and labor migration.

He was previously engaged as writer, researcher and consultant by several organizations including media outfits like Today Independent Daily News and Manila Times Publishing Corporation as well as research and consultancy firms like Louise Berger International and the Ateneo Center for Social Policy and Public Affairs. In 2005, Mr. Llorito was a fellow of the US State Department’s International Visitors Program (IVP) for Leadership in Print Journalism where he had the chance to interact with executives and editors of leading U.S. media organizations.

Recent awards include: 2006 Jaime V. Ongpin Awards for Excellence in Journalism (Explanatory Category); 2006 Australian Ambassador’s Choice Awards for his articles on globalization and how it’s transforming labor-management relations; the Jose Burgos Awards for Biotechnology Journalism (finalist, best feature category) for his stories on biofuels; and the 2005 Jaime V. Ongpin Awards for Excellence in Investigative Journalism (top ten finalist) for his exposes on land titling scams.

Mr. Llorito has a master’s degree in urban and regional planning from the University of the Philippines and a bachelor of arts in political science from the Mindanao State University in Marawi City in Southern Philippines.


Mara Lee
Associate Producer, NPR Continuous News Desk
Washington, DC

Mara Lee is an associate producer with the continuous news desk at National Public Radio (NPR), a producer and distributor of news, talk, and entertainment programming. A not-for-profit membership organization, NPR serves an audience of 26 million Americans each week in partnership with more than 800 independently operated public radio stations. The website, npr.org, includes original online content as well as audio streaming and 10 years of archived audio.

Before joining NPR in February 2007, Ms. Lee worked as a Washington correspondent for the Evansville, Indiana, Courier & Press, in the Scripps Howard bureau. In that job, she covered the races of two Republican incumbents who were defeated in the November 2006 election, part of a wave of defeats that led to the Democratic takeover of Congress. She also covered the then-head of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, Senator Dick Lugar.

From 1996 to 2005, Ms. Lee worked in Ohio, first at Mansfield, Ohio’s News Journal, and for the last six years, at the Dayton Daily News. In Dayton, she began covering economics as part of the U.S. Census beat. She also did a two-day series in 2004 about white-collar offshoring in Ohio workplaces. That series, “Dayton to Delhi; Outsourcing: Jobs in Jeopardy?” won awards at the state and national levels. The Cleveland Press Club named it as best business writing in the state that year. It was also a finalist for the Livingston Awards, a national contest recognizing journalists younger than 35 from TV, radio and print. She also has received awards for breaking news and for feature writing from the Associated Press and Society for Professional Journalists. Economic issues are prominent in Ohio politics, as the state continues to be battered by manufacturing declines, and it trails many states on the coasts in attracting investment and jobs. Before going to Ohio, she worked at a trade magazine, Washington Technology, and at newspapers in Alabama, Virginia and North Carolina.

Ms. Lee has a B.S. in journalism from the University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill, 1993. Past professional training has included the Paul Miller Fellowship for Washington reporters, and a Knight Center fellowship about urban and suburban issues.


Long Nguyen Dang Vu
Journalist and News/Feature Editor, The Vietnam Investment Review
Hanoi, Vietnam

Long Nguyen Dang Vu is a journalist and news/feature editor for the Vietnam Investment Review (VIR) which publishes six issues per week with a single issue circulation of 120,000 copies. VIR is printed in two versions, English and Vietnamese.

Before, moving to VIR seven years ago, Mr. Long worked as a full-time journalist for the Vietnam Business Forum and the Vietnam Economic Times. In addition to his work at VIR, Mr. Long also assists with editing a commercial and economic program titled: “The Market 24 Hours” for Vietnam’s national television broadcasting station and contributes stories to the London headquartered online newspaper, http://www.scidev.net/. In his more than 10 years working as journalist, Mr. Long has written thousands of stories and articles related to both social and economic issues which have been printed in dozens of domestic and foreign newspapers.

Mr. Long received scholarships to attend an economic and financial reporting course in Berlin organized by the International Institute for Journalism based in Germany and the 4th World Conference of Science Journalists in Montreal organized by the World Federation of Science Journalists and the Canadian Science Writers’ Association. In addition, he has participated in many short term workshops and courses related to economic journalism in many countries world-wide.

Mr. Long has a degree in English translation and interpretation from the Hanoi University of Foreign Studies, and has received certificates in Business and Financial Economic Reporting and Online Advance Business and Economic Reporting granted by the International Institute for Journalism in Berlin.

Sidhartha
Economics Editor, The Times of India
New Delhi, India

Sidhartha is Economics Editor in The Times of India, responsible for tracking and analyzing developments on economic policy and in the world of business. The Times of India is India’s largest English language newspaper and is part of Bennett Coleman & Co Ltd, the largest media house, with significant presence in the print media through publications like The Economic Times, Navbharat Times and Femina, besides interests in television and radio stations.

Sidhartha joined The Times of India in January 2006 from Business Standard, a leading financial daily, after an eight year stint. Starting in the weekend section of Business Standard in 1998, writing features on business, personal finance and motoring, over the years, he has tracked various sectors ranging from telecommunications, energy, trade, finance and micro and macro-economic policy.

He graduated in economics from Delhi University’s Ramjas College in 1997, and went on to complete a post-graduate diploma course in print journalism from the Indian Institute of Mass Communication, New Delhi.


Alfred Siew
Technology Correspondent, The Straits Times
Singapore

Alfred Siew is a correspondent with The Straits Times, the largest daily newspaper in Singapore, covering the technology beat for the daily newspaper, as well as the weekly infocomm magazine called Digital Life. He writes news stories, features, commentaries and product reviews for both the main section of The Straits Times and Digital Life. Besides writing, he also supervises and leads packages for in-depth reports. He has been with the Singapore Press Holdings, which publishes The Straits Times, for close to eight years.

Technology issues that Mr. Siew currently covers include: new media, and how young users are changing the rules for the Internet; technology and government, and how initiatives from the public sector can move or slow down adoption of technology and open/clamp up markets; the benefits of technology adoption; and the latest mobile devices, and how consumer habits are changing with every new gizmo that hits the shelves.

Mr. Siew has won several awards, most recently for his coverage of the Internet outage on Boxing Day 2006 that affected most parts of East Asia resulting from an earthquake off the Taiwan coast that cut off several undersea telecom cables.

Mr. Siew graduated in 1999 with a bachelor of communications studies with honours from the Nanyang Technological University in Singapore. While in school, he ran a dot.com business called Mediagate Communications that hosted and designed websites for small and medium businesses. The company was born in August 1996, and closed shop in June 1999, just as the dot.com craze hit fever pitch.

Teramoto Seiji
Staff Writer, Department of Economy, Chunichi Shimbun
Nagoya, Japan

Teramoto Seiji has worked for Chunichi Shimbun as a staff writer for almost 20 years. Chunichi Shimbun, one of the biggest Japanese daily newspapers is based in Nagoya, close to the headquarters of Toyota. The combined circulation is more 5 million. It also has over 10 overseas branch offices, including Washington D.C, New York, London, Paris, Berlin, Moscow, Cairo, Bangkok, Manila, Beijing, Shanghai, Seoul.

Mr. Teramoto currently is responsible for covering the automobile industry, especially Toyota, as a chief writer in the department of economy. Prior to this, he was a correspondent and a deputy of the New York branch office from 2002 to 2005. In New York, he primarily wrote articles about the U.S economy and United Nations, but he also covered political issues including post 9/11 policy shifts and the beginning of the Iraq War. Mr. Teramoto started his career with the Chunichi Shimbun in April, 1988. After working at the Fukui branch office, he began to work in the department of economy in 1990 and covered manufacturing companies, retail business and the energy industry. His first exposure to the United States was a four week journalist program sponsored by the U.S. State Department in 1997. In 1998, he studied at West Virginia University for one year with financial support from Chunichi Shimbun.

Mr. Teramoto graduated from Kanazawa University, one of Japan’s National Universities, with a bachelor’s degree in economics.

Saturday, March 10, 2007

Composite LEI: let the good times roll!

Will the Philippine economy maintain its growth momentum? Well, the composite leading economic indicator (LEI) which serves as an early warning system for the economy released recently by the National Statistical Coordination Board (NSCB) says yes.

"The composite leading economic indicator (LEI) moves up in the first quarter of
2007, rising to 0.170 from 0.107 in the last quarter of 2006. Of the
eleven indicators that make up the composite LEI, four contributed positively to
the LEI for the first quarter of 2007. The positive contributors – beginning
with the largest positive contributor – were stock price index, exchange rate,
money supply and new businesses. The negative contributors - beginning with the
largest negative contributor – were tourist arrivals, electric energy
consumption, hotel occupancy, wholesale price index, merchandise imports,
consumer price index, and terms of trade. Positive contributors accounted for
72.1 percent of total contribution, outweighing negative contributors at 27.9
percent share."


What does it mean to have rising LEI? NSCB explains:

"The LEIS involves the study of the behavior of indicators that consistently move upward or downward before the actual expansion or contraction of overall economic activity. The system is based on an empirical observation that the cycles of many economic data series are related to the cycles of total business activity, i.e. they expand in general when business is growing and contract when business is shrinking. The LEIS was institutionalized to provide advance information on the direction of the country’s economic activity/performance in the short run."

Encouraging signs for the economy so far. Last week, the
Philippine Institute for Development Studies (PIDS), a government think tank, predicted a 5.8 percent GDP growth rate for the Philippine economy in 2007. Let the good times roll!

Wednesday, March 07, 2007

Just keep on ranting, you hear?!

Hmmn, it seems like my blog do get some attention sometimes. Today, Philippine Daily Inquirer columnist Manuel Quezon cited the editorial I wrote for BusinessMirror which I archived in my blog Philippines Without Borders about to whose credit the country’s economic performance should go. I argued the government doesn’t deserve it because all along the party in power has simply been too busy putting out political fires. Neither should the Opposition denigrate the gains of the economy for they are real gains achieved by the private sector, overseas Filipino workers, and the local entrepreneur.

Quezon said:
And I’d like to know what the administration and opposition have to say about
David Llorito’s belief that the administration has been too busy playing “whack-a-mole,” that is, stamping out scandals of its own making, to really attend to what it claims it has been doing all along -- forgoing politics and focusing on the economy. As
Llorito puts it, “We could have achieved some more, probably on a par with our
fast-growing neighbors, if only the government had been really attentive to the
pulse of the economy.”

By way of proving his point, Llorito wrote that as far as the administration claim of an improved economy, “these are real gains, alright, but in truth Malacañang has little to do with it at all. A look at the national income accounts shows the country’s growth was largely driven by consumption financed by remittances, the rapid growth of cyberservices and the recovery in the export sector. The dynamics of these growth drivers have nothing to do with Palace occupants.”
Moral lesson? To all bloggers out there, just keep on ranting. You might yet get an ear or two and, who knows, you may even change the world for the better. Or worse.

Dangers from the emerging multipolar world

A wide, wild world
An Editorial I wrote for BusinessMirror, Posted March 8, 2007

ANALYSTS attributed last week’s global stock market plunge to two major factors, namely the fall in China’s stock market after the Chinese government announced a crackdown on stock price manipulators and the recent negative data coming from the United States.

What many analysts did not focus on so much is that the event may signal that we are now in a “post-US” world that could prove to be full of uncertainties.

We used to say that when America sneezes, the rest of the world catches cold. These days, following last week’s stock market plunge, analysts are wondering whether or not the country will catch fever.

Concerns over the prospects of the economy saw the government and private sector analysts trying to spin the issue down. Our fundamentals, they say, are sound. The local economy, they say, won’t be hurt because only the rich play in the stock market. Our main drivers of growth are dollar remittances by overseas Filipinos. Recovery, they say, is going to be immediate.

Theirs is strange behavior because in reality no one knows how the markets globally would behave. Trading in the stock market is all about greed and no rocket scientist has yet figured out how to ride and predict the behavior of this unruly tiger.

The current scene is a sea change from a period when all an analyst would do to divine the country’s prospects is by just looking at America’s economic vitals. Is America’s consumer-confidence high? Are Americans building more houses? Are they buying more cars and gadgets? Is the American economy generating more jobs? These were the common questions asked. If the numbers look good, we were then also supposed to feel good, as it would mean rising purchases of our exports.

Now analysts are increasingly watching the moves of policymakers in China. And rightly so because, combined with Hong Kong, China these days accounts for 18 percent of the country’s merchandise exports. Many of our business elite are doing business there and local economic managers are hoping that by hitching our fortunes to the Chinese star, we might just grow out of our own misery. So overall, it’s a nice development since, with diversifying markets and global linkages, we could develop greater capability to deal with external shocks.

Indeed, China is currently the main driver of global economic growth. This trend is part of the ever-increasing spatial shift in wealth creation toward the Asia-Pacific region. Recent statistics show that the combined output of “emerging economies” now account for about half of the global output. “Emerging economies” here are actually mostly about China, India, Korea, Singapore, Russia. That means we are right smack in the vortex of these wealth-creating powerhouses. If we could play our cards well, we might yet achieve the higher growth levels and prosperity that we all desire. Or so they say.

With this spatial shift in wealth creation towards the Asia-Pacific necessarily comes a shift of political power as well. Observers wary of American dominance in global affairs are therefore happy that this trend may yet usher in a “multipolar world.” Certainly, a diversifying global market, coupled with the shift towards multipolar international relations, should sound like an ideal state for a globalizing world order. And yet, it’s in this situation that we are starting to raise our doubts about the future.

Why? Because of two things. First, it means that there wouldn’t be anyone to lead the global economy toward a meaningful conclusion of the Doha Round of Trade negotiations. There’s no doubt that expansion of global trade in the last two decades came as a result of the opening of markets with the signing of the Uruguay Round agreement. That agreement, which ushered in the World Trade Organization, brought wealth to the Asia-Pacific through greater flows of investments, trade in goods and services, and technology. Initially, the Europeans blocked the Uruguay Round but the leadership of America under Bill Clinton broke the deadlock. Specifically, European intransigence gave way to compromise when Bill Clinton pushed hard for free trade within the region through the Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation (Apec).

But the gains from the Uruguay Round agreement proved inadequate to address poverty in many nations; hence the Doha round emerged. But with President George W. Bush preoccupied with the “war on terror” and the continuing flurry of bad news in Iraq and Afghanistan, America has been distracted from playing a leading role in the negotiations.

Its war on terror and America’s worsening twin deficits have lowered its prestige and ability to exert positive influence. Without such leadership, it’s possible the world will descend into the chaos of regional trade blocs that distort the flow of trade.

And second, given the continuing flow of investments and the transfer of jobs to Asia-Pacific, some demagogic politicians in the West might yet resort to protectionist policies that will harm the global economy. Given the fact that close to 60 percent of the country’s GDP is accounted for by the globalized sectors, among the first to be hit by such policies would be the Philippines.

This is a very dark scenario, of course, but possible—given the fact that no one among the current global players and emerging ones has what it takes to lead the world toward a more liberal trading order. Not Europe, which is not capable of generating consensus on the reform of its own Common Agricultural Policy. It’s too fixated on its own navel to be an economic global leader. Not Japan, which is scrambling to address its own problems, including the graying of its population. Not China, whose main preoccupation is grabbing every available natural resource to fuel its own frenetic growth.

And certainly not Putin’s Russia. Because of rising prices of natural gas and oil, Russia has been experiencing rapid economic growth and accumulated quite a stash of cash to bully its neighbors. It certainly has gained a lot of economic clout but it’s the kind that sends shivers down people’s spines.

Consider this: Russia’s rise to power and influence came largely from the turbulence generated by uncertainties in the oil-producing region, specifically the Persian Gulf and the Middle East. Apparently, it doesn’t seem to have any economic incentive for a geographically stable Middle East.

A safer multipolar world? We should think again and figure out how to put up the Philippine economy’s defenses
.

Monday, March 05, 2007

The "new economy" in our midst

BEST new BPO locator of the year: Dell Philippines. Best midsized BPO company of the year: Leverage Systems Technologies. Most innovative BPO of the year: Transprocure Corp. Fastest-growing BPO company of the year: Teletech. Best BPO employer of the year: Convergys Philippines. And the BPO company of the year: Accenture.

People might be wondering if the brave new world of the “new economy,” a buzzword that has been associated with the information revolution, has reached our shores. We say “yes,” and the companies mentioned above are among the best in our midst, at least for the year 2007.

On Thursday evening the Canadian Chamber of Commerce—in partnership with the Business Processing Association Philippines (BPAP) and other organizations, including this paper—gave out several awards in recognition of their contributions to the economy.

The awards are rightly helping the public become more aware of their contributions because right now this segment of the Philippine economy is giving lots of excitement and promise to young entrepreneurs and workers. It has even started to create a positive impact on other sectors of the economy, including real estate, wholesale and retail, and even food and beverage manufacturing.

Nowhere is its impact more visible than in the property sector. Following the Asian financial crisis, office vacancy rates in the country’s urban centers like Makati and Ortigas went as high as 50 percent. As the “new economy” crept in, office vacancies went down so fast that even property developers were caught nearly napping.

These days, vacancies in prime and grade A office—those really nice and carefully designed office spaces with accreditation from the Philippine Economic Zone Authority—are all of just over 1 percent. That explains the frenetic construction in Makati, as well as in Fort Bonifacio. It’s likely that construction activities will really move faster this year.

If the predictions of its drumbeaters prove true, we are going to see this segment of the economy employing close to a million workers and generating more than $12 billion worth of services exports. At that size, the industry, property consultants say, would require close to 3-million square meters of office spaces. Hence, developers have to rush because if they fail to supply the spaces required by the BPO, the industry might suffer office-space shortages.

Right now, existing supply of offices plus those in the pipeline until 2010 would total 1.6-million square meters. That would mean a shortage of about 1.4-million square meters. It’s a kind of problem this country should be happy to have.

A million workers for the industry might seem too ambitious, but if one looks at the profile of these industries, there are reasons to be optimistic. They are highly labor-intensive. Teletech, for instance, has more than 10,000 employees. Convergys has 11,000. Many others are employing close to these numbers, and the list of companies keeps growing.

We mentioned the winning companies above to highlight how far the Philippines has gone in terms of developing its capabilities in these emerging knowledge-driven industries. The winners came from varied sectors, including software development, procurement-transaction processing, customer care, global management consulting, legal support and publishing, among many other activities. The judges, we have learned, really had a hard time determining the winners, an indication that what we have here in the Philippines are highly competitive and dynamic global players.

It should not be a surprise because way back in 2000, when the Department of Trade and Industry started plotting out measures to attract call centers, there was practically no BPO to speak of, except maybe some animation companies that have been here in the Philippine since the ’80s. Now, estimates from the BPAP indicate that the industry employs about 250,000 people and earns more than $3 billion a year. In 2007, assuming the same frenetic growth it has achieved in the last five years, the industry might yet generate US$4.9 billion.

The term “new economy” emerged in the ’90s as a way to describe the economies of advanced countries that underwent transformation from being industry-led to services-led, driven by information technology. Enthusiasts then thought that with extensive use of information technology, economies would enjoy steady growth and low unemployment. Others came even to declare that the business cycles of boom and bust had ended and that economies, having found Shangri-la, will prosper forever.

That proved illusory with the dot.com bubble in 1995-2000 that saw many technology stocks crashing down to terra firma when it burst. The global recession that followed discredited the “new-economy” prophets. Nevertheless, the term new economy continues to gain currency as global companies took to heart its doctrine that companies should “focus on their core competencies” and outsource the rest through the use of information technology.

In the new economy, profits are supposed to come from company intangibles like brands, intellectual properties, technical capabilities and reputation. Routine functions like back-office operations, manufacturing, and customer care could be outsourced elsewhere, preferably in low-cost locations in the developing countries.

That’s how we came to have all these outsourcing companies in our midst. And their presence is expanding rapidly. It’s new metamorphosis is the knowledge-process outsourcing (KPO) where local MBAs, engineers, and economists perform analytics like risk analysis for global corporations and organizations. And if we continue to play our cards well, we might yet end up duplicating India’s success in this business.

Playing our cards right means that the country should maintain its competitiveness in this sector. There’s no doubt that the private sector is mobilizing their resources to meet the challenge. The Ayalas, for instance, are investing billions putting up the buildings needed by the BPO. The conglomerate is also investing heavily in the industry, especially in KPO. There are indications that Rockwell Land of the Lopezes is also moving in the same direction.

The only kinks so far are in the public sector, where efforts to restore the importance of English in the classrooms through legislation has not been moving. We still haven’t heard of any major initiative to reform and upgrade the country’s education system. We have yet to see how the government is improving the country’s capability in the sciences and mathematics. Malacañang, as well as our educators in the private sector, therefore, should look at these issues as soon as possible, so we could sustain the momentum in embracing the new economy.

Wednesday, February 28, 2007

Philippine mid-term elections: politicians should spare the economy

WILL the politicians, both from the opposition and the administration, please stop politicizing the country’s economy? Will they please stop using it as fodder for election propaganda? This is the only way we can sustain the modest growth we have achieved so far.

It’s funny that Malacañang keeps on harping about its supposed “economic performance,” citing the 5-percent to 6-percent growth rate achieved in the last three years, the gains in the stock market, the recovery of exports, among others, as part of the ruling party’s campaign spiels.


These are real gains, alright, but in truth Malacañang has little to do with it at all. A look at the national income accounts shows the country’s growth was largely driven by consumption financed by remittances, the rapid growth of cyberservices and the recovery in the export sector. The dynamics of these growth drivers have nothing to do with Palace occupants.

In the last three years, Malacañang has simply being doing whack-a-mole, suppressing scandal after scandal and crisis after political crisis that pop up here and there, while forgetting to enact the annual budget or repair a bridge or a road that farmers needed to bring their produce to the market.

If one looks at the national income accounts, one sees that the government expenditures in the last three years are flat or negative despite the fact that the government has been collecting higher VAT rates (12 percent) and higher corporate taxes (35 percent). In fact, the government has actually been reversing the policy reforms that the country achieved after the 1986 Edsa people power revolution. The most recent example is the increase in tariff rates for steel products from 3 percent to 7 percent—one that would surely penalize the construction sector.

So the real score is that we have achieved such modest growth rates despite having political leaders hobbling us. We could have achieved some more, probably on a par with our fast-growing neighbors, if only the government had been really attentive to the pulse of the economy.

But it’s also wrong for the opposition to denigrate the gains of the economy, no matter how modest by Chinese or Indian standards. The opposition, in a full page ad in one newspaper, said the country’s economic gains are “a mirage” and that all of them are “insignificant.” That’s unfair.

These growth rates are neither a mirage nor too insignificant to bother about, because they are the gains contributed by the country’s private business sector, the entrepreneurs, foreign investors and the OFWs themselves who sacrificed a lot just to send the dollars that the country badly needs. Everybody should recognize this fact. Are the 250,000 new jobs created by outsourcing a mirage? Is the $47-billion export generated by the private sector, about $30 billion of which came from electronics, insignificant?

For all the talk about China being the world’s factory, the fact remains that the Philippine manufacturing sector has been doing well at 4-percent to 5-percent growth rates in the last three years. Even economist Cielito Habito, former director general of Neda, recognizes this fact.

Somehow, the billions of dollars being sent home by overseas Filipinos have something to do with this. This money is converted into purchases of products produced by our factories in the same way that they keep the malls and the property sector booming. But we should credit the ingenuity of our factory managers and workers for holding their ground against competing products here and in the world markets.

Undeniably, joblessness is still high in the Philippines. It’s also true that the country’s economic growth is “narrow” as most critics are wont to say. Being driven largely by the services sector, the benefits so far have largely been felt by those in urban areas. But the Philippines has to start somewhere and the numbers these days say there are growth areas the country could work on to accelerate and broaden the economic base.

Asian tigers like Taiwan and South Korea took a decade or two of sustained 5-percent to 7-percent economic growth before they could address massive poverty. These days, China and India have been growing at 8 percent to 10 percent and yet, if we look beyond the surface, they still have a lot of things to do to touch the lives of their miserable masses.

Recent reports by international organizations, such as the International Labor Organization and the United Nations Development Program, continue to deplore jobless growth in these parts of the Asia-Pacific Region. So these countries must sustain that growth trajectory over the next decade before one sees a qualitative change in the lives of their impoverished sectors.

It’s the same tack that we should do, besides the usual equity-enhancing measures—and politicians should not reduce our chances for doing so by muddling the issues and denigrating our modest gains.

In international conferences, one often observes that while other countries discuss their gains and the “challenges” they need to overcome to usher in growth, Filipinos are beating their breasts—telling the whole world things are not changing, the Philippines is doomed forever and only the Second Coming of Christ could save the Filipino from damnation. No wonder other countries look down on us despite positive changes we’ve achieved. Such self-defeating negativity from what should have been more enlightened Filipinos, are aggravated by the sweeping remarks of political leaders from either side of the fence who interpret the data to either demolish the other or embellish one’s accomplishment.

From the structural point of view, what enabled the country from achieving such modest growth is the increasing share of the globalized sectors of the economy. The rough estimate seems to be that these sectors now account for more than 60 percent of the country’s GDP. That had somehow partially shielded the economy by the gyrations of Philippine politics. They are mostly the fruits of the painstaking policy reforms started by President Corazon Aquino after the 1986 Edsa revolution and were sustained by succeeding administrations. Specifically, the deregulation and infusion of more competition in transportation, storage and communications industries, as well as reforms in the country’s tariff system.

The task, therefore, for both the ruling coalition and the opposition is to strengthen these dynamics by sparing the economy from becoming collateral damage in their exchanges of political firebombs.

Certainly, debates about the economy are part of the political process. In presidential elections in the US, Republicans would rather look about America being a “house on the hill” while Democrats hammer on the “great American dream” and how to bring ordinary people there. Our politicians could do no less and leave hard-nosed economic analysis to independent parties that have no hidden agenda.

Monday, February 26, 2007

Daily slaughter of the innocents

There are murderers on the loose in Metro Manila. They have killed 196 people and injured 4,339 persons in the metropolis in 2006. These numbers mean that they maim 12 persons each day and kill one every other day. No, they are not the usual gun-toting killers because their favorite weapons are their vehicles: cars, trucks, buses and jeepneys.

If we assume the same figure each year, it means that more than a thousand innocent people died and 22,000 injured in the last five years. Certainly, this is massacre using the bluntest of weapons. But the greatest tragedy of all is that the Philippine society as a whole doesn’t seem to care. Politicians, “civil-society” groups, do-gooders and the gallery of save-the-world types don’t even mention this mayhem in the streets.

The killers are vehicle drivers and their victims: the pedestrians, as reported by the “Metro Manila Accident Reporting and Analysis System” of the Metropolitan Manila Development Authority (MMDA).

What this statistical report suggests is that Metro Manila, especially cities like Quezon City and Makati, has become a killer zone, a cannibal of its own children.

What’s the government doing about this now? We would like to know because we really don’t know who will be fatally hit by the bus next time. It might be the ones close to our hearts: our children crossing the streets from schools, our grandparents buying medicine, our spouse carrying food stuff from the grocery stores. It may be us.

Policymakers in this country, starting right at the Office of the President or the Department of Transportation and Communications, down to MMDA and the local government units, should really take this issue seriously. By the sheer volume of the victims, this issue should dwarf all other issues related to health and the loss to lives and limb. More so because it almost assumes the proportion of class conflict: pedestrians, the hoi polloi, versus vehicle owners.

That seems to be an oversimplification but the truth is that 70 percent of travel demand, or seven out of 10 people, move around to work, home and leisure, using public transport. That should suggest that those who are killed—those almost 196 unfortunate souls killed each day and 200 injured—mostly belong to the poorer segments of society who can’t afford the latest or even the second-hand beaten-up Toyota or Nissan.

At the root of this problem is attitudinal. Drivers and vehicle owners here simply don’t respect pedestrians. And we guess it reflects the contempt of the haves toward the have-nots in society.

Many bus or jeepney drivers are peons themselves but, because of lack of proper orientation and training on proper driving behavior, many simply carry the same negative attitude toward pedestrians. When a pedestrian raises a hand to signal an intention to cross, drivers here would simply blow their horns as they press the accelerator to bully pedestrians off the street. No wonder, accidents are common.

The immediate solution goes right smack to better traffic law enforcement. For long, traffic managers in this country have allowed rascals behind the wheels to go around violating traffic rules, especially on speed limits and traffic lights.

Of course, most of the drivers here actually don’t know traffic rules as it is common knowledge that people from the Land Transportation Office (LTO) would issue them licenses anyway —presumably for a fee. Thus, revamping LTO’s licensing system, making it transparent, is certainly one solution. If the government has the will, the government may actually outsource this function where the private sector could bid for the right to deliver this service based on certain criteria like cost-effectiveness, transparency and effectiveness.

Traffic managers and enforcers themselves, of course, are part of the problem. Just like vehicle owners and drivers who see pedestrians as lesser mortals, people who run these traffic management agencies have the same attitude toward the ordinary man on the street.

They see pedestrians as a nuisance who should get out of the way of vehicle traffic. They see them as ignorant mortals, nay cattle, to be prodded and controlled against cages and steel barriers. Thus, instead of enforcing the rules on driving behavior, government agencies like the MMDA simply penalize pedestrians even more by establishing cages and barriers that would even pin down and restrict people’s movements, thus endangering people’s lives.

Just try taking a bus at Edsa adjacent to SM in Makati City and see how the cages constructed by the MMDA under Bayani Fernando are a veritable death trap should a stampede occur. This is the only country that uses cattle cages and chicken wires to control pedestrians and traffic flow. We should be ashamed of this utterly fascistic form of urban “management.”

Somehow, this problem may reflect the greater social malaise that afflicts Philippine society. By some technical definition, more than half of the Philippine population lives in “urban areas.” But at heart, the average Filipino is still a hillbilly whose frame of mind does not transcend beyond his immediate family, network of friends and extended relatives.

Unlike countries that underwent an industrial revolution where people had to live by the rules and rigidity of a synchronized second-wave economy, the Pinoy, the rural dweller trapped in the urban jungle, has not learned to live properly in an urbanized setting. Thus he snarls when a pedestrian, a lesser mortal, gets in the way. And sometimes he hurts or kills them—“accidentally.”

Most Asian countries of course also did not experience industrial revolution to engender urbanity in their citizens. But the State came to fore to perform such function. The State, through its powers in traffic management, land-use planning and day-to-day urban management, played a crucial role, something that we sorely lack here in the Philippines.

That is why all sectors of society—especially schools, churches, businesses and civil-society groups—should help in addressing this problem. We need to bring the Filipino drivers’ attitudes and value systems into the 21st century.

We have no choice but to do it, otherwise the daily slaughter of the innocents in the streets will continue.

Wednesday, February 21, 2007

Resolving the legitimacy issue is key to the success of Plan 789

IT is gratifying to see the government trying to rev up the economy so we could achieve a 7-9 percent growth in the country’s gross domestic product (GDP). It’s something worth noting because that means that finally, no less than the President herself has seen the futility of just cruising and muddling through a 5-6 percent growth that we have achieved in the last three years. Such level of growth has been quite decent compared to our performance a decade ago, but it has not been good enough to soak up joblessness in the country. Yes, there are growing opportunities for fresh graduates, especially those who have the skill and spunk to join the growing business process outsourcing industry. But the rate of job creation has been so slow to snatch the ordinary guys off the desperation of the streets. The rate of growth we have is not even enough to provide illusions to all those who want to be janitors in those gleaming towers housing the BPOs. Of course, the 5-6 percent is actually mediocre if we compare ourselves with immediate neighbors China, India, and Vietnam, who are having problems with the opposite—sizzling speed in the growth of their economies.

Thus, the raising of our ambition to achieve 7-9 percent growth in the next few years is a refreshing change. And it’s nice to hear the private sector is behind this idea. But can this really be achieved? We really hope so because it’s the only way we could really address joblessness and, ultimately, poverty.

Certainly, the external environment seems to be favorable enough. Despite all the talk about the cooling of the American economy and its worsening budget and trade deficit problems, the emerging economies (read China, India and the other dragons in East Asia) are expected to grow briskly at more than 7 percent. There is also talk about the possible slowing down in demand for electronics, but industry leaders here continue to expect robust sales due to the increasing use of microchips in cars, trucks, gadgets, and computers. The recent release of Microsoft Vista may even spur more demand for electronics. Barring any major economic and geopolitical shocks (like a sudden surge in global crude prices, conflagration in the Gulf or another terrorist attack at the scale of 911), the world economy may yet be relied upon to help us through that 7-8-9 ambition of ours.

We are happy to note that some domestic ingredients are actually present. Inflation is tapering off, the government’s finances are improving, interest rates are down, the dollar remittances are surging, the cyberservices sector is growing fast. Foreign direct investments numbers are improving quickly, an indication we are slowly regaining business confidence among foreign investors. And most of all, property analysts are saying that a construction boom is about to kick off as the country’s major business centers like Makati and Ortigas are running out of space for the burgeoning BPOs.

There are worrying trends, however. Despite the decent growth rates achieved so far, domestic investments are not rising, as indicated by the weak capital formation figures. Business people are not investing in durable equipment, nor are agribusiness entrepreneurs putting money in breeding stocks and orchard. Imports especially of capital goods are also not rising. Private construction in the last three years has also been flat. What this is saying is that local investors are not really putting a stake in the economy yet.

And why? One could only speculate, but we believe the attitude among business people is probably related to the continuing legitimacy issue of the Arroyo government. Investors are waiting if the coming election could resolve this legitimacy issue. Investors are “rational people”; they are not going to stake their money if they think the continuing question of legitimacy would linger. It’s no use expanding your factory and hiring more workers if you know this issue would distract Malacañang’s occupants into squandering public resources in politically-motivated and therefore economically wasteful expenditures that would ultimately hurt the economy. It’s no use putting money for the future, knowing that Malacañang dwellers are on purely survival mode and are distracted from governing.

The legitimacy issue, of course, could probably be addressed by a clean and honest election this coming May. At least, that’s what we are hoping for. What is of concern, though, is the notion that the ruling powers might not really be committed to such an exercise. Why? One reason is the continuing dream among top leaders of the Executive, and their allies in the House of Representatives, for charter change. According to political analyst Mario Taguiwalo, president of National Institute for Policy Studies, it’s obvious that a clean and honest election would only strengthen the Senate, which would thus resist any move to abolish it through Charter change. That means that cynically, they might just tarnish the image of the Senate by committing massive fraud, thus prompting an exasperated public to think that abolishing the Senate through cha-cha might just be the right thing. This is not to say that the ruling party is right now hatching this malevolent plot. But the strong temptation is there, especially that—based on the Pulse Asia survey—only a few candidates in the Team Unity are winnable. Some of the candidates may think that, should they go down, they might as well bring the house, nay the country, down.

That’s the worst “1-2-3 [double cross] scenario,” of course, and one hopes it won’t happen again, or we might as well kiss “7-8-9” goodbye. There’s so much at stake here, the least of which is the budding recovery achieved in the last three years. All well-meaning citizens should thus help see to it that we have such a clean and honest election for the sake of the country.

Crossing our fingers, what we would like to see—as enunciated well by Mr Taguiwalo at Wednesday’s Ateneo Eagle Watch briefing—is a mid-term electoral process that would plant the seeds for the election of a viable, credible and legitimate administration in 2010. That way, we could achieve stability and gain the political capital that the government could mobilize for the right economic and social reforms. The 7-8-9 dream seems a long shot, but who knows, given such a credible election providing leaven for genuine reform and boosting economic activity, it might be doable yet.

Monday, February 19, 2007

Is PPA a fixer for port monopolists?

IS the Philippine Ports Authority (PPA) an agent of some monopolists or what? Whose interest does it represent? These questions have been raised because it seems that it’s acting like a fixer for those who are out to monopolize North Harbor should the government pursue its privatization.

The government has lately been mulling over the privatization of the strategic port. It’s the right thing to do at this time. Governments in this country have always tried to bite more than they could chew, and intervened in economic spheres where they should not. That’s mainly why we ended up with a corrupt, bloated, and sluggish bureaucracy that can’t do anything other than hurt the country’s prospects for growth and development.

But if we have to privatize North Harbor, why should we turn it over to private monopoly? That would be no different from turning over the control of a strategic economic infrastructure from the hands of a publicly paid rent-seeking posse to a group of private capitalist raiders out to fleece the national interest.

We know for a fact that the PPA is owned by the government and therefore we expect it to represent the common good. The government has been saying it’s for deregulation, privatization, and greater competition to promote greater efficiency in the economy. One therefore logically expects the PPA to toe this policy line. But what the PPA has been saying vis-à-vis this issue of North Harbor privatization clearly goes against government policy.
PPA is saying that it prefers a single operator for the North Harbor to “make it attractive to the private sector,” as well as “to prevent cut-throat competition.”

Certainly, any private sector salivates at the prospect of solely controlling North Harbor. Without any competition, any private sector operator could raise prices on a whim without modernizing the port’s facilities. Without a benchmark by which the operator’s performance could be measured against, how do we know if public interest is being screwed or not? But why is the PPA so afraid of “cut-throat competition?” Is it trying to protect certain vested interests in the port business?

Certainly, business people hate and fear competition. They want market dominance all the time. But we all know that competition benefits society as a whole and therefore it is good to ensure competition among the players all the time.

It’s the “cut-throat” competition among telecommunication companies that brought millions of landlines to the provinces and cellular phones to just about anybody else. It’s this cut-throat competition that gave us Internet connectivity. And it’s cut-throat competition among retailers that is driving down inflation rates, thus enabling us to stretch our purchasing power.

A few years ago, we were happy to have dial-up Internet even though it took an eternity to get connected to the Web. Now, a growing number of people are having broadband and, thanks to “cut-throat competition,” high-speed Internet will soon be ubiquitous like TV, thus extending the benefit of the Information Revolution to the broader segment of the population. And most of all, it’s cut-throat competition that brought us all the economic and telecommunications infrastructure that, in turn, also attracted the $3-billion cyberservices industry and giving jobs and hopes to more than 250,000 young people.

If we can do that in telecommunications as well as in other sectors of the Philippine economy, why can’t we do it in port operations and shipping?

Yes, cut-throat competition brings wealth and progress. We are therefore better off having a competitive port operations business in the country. We have more than 7,000 islands in the country and many of them are still suffering in the limbo of disconnectedness, poverty and unrest because for too long the government has tolerated a one-port-one-operator policy. For so long, most of our ports have been operated by monopolies, the reason why farmers and fishers in the far reaches of the archipelago couldn’t sell their produce at competitive prices. Compared with our neighbors, our cost of production in the farms and agribusiness plantations is comparable with our neighbors. Yet we couldn’t compete with them because of higher shipping and transport costs. And shipping and transport costs are high primarily because producers don’t have much choice.

Take the case of Mindanao. It is rich in natural resources, its lands are fertile and productive, and its seas are awash with the bounties of the sea. And yet, a significant part of its population is wretchedly poor and some of its nooks and crannies are havens for criminals and terrorists. Why? It’s because development and progress couldn’t get to these isolated places. Places like Bukidnon, the Cotabato provinces and Wa-o in Lanao del Sur produce the best corn in the land needed by the fast-growing livestock and poultry sector. And yet farmers in these places couldn’t sell their corn at profitable prices because the shipping cost is high. The joke until this day is that it’s cheaper to import corn from Argentina than get it from Mindanao.

These days we always wonder why “development” has always been confined to Metro Manila, Calabarzon, and to the major cities of Cebu and Davao. We always thought that we need more strategic infrastructure facilities to link these economic centers to the hinterlands.

This is true but it’s only half the story. The other side of the coin is the one-port, one-operator rule being encouraged by the PPA. If we want to ensure that growth spreads to the countryside we better scrap this policy. If we have to privatize the North Harbor, we better make sure that what we are going to put in place is a competitive environment for operators, as well as for those who are using them.It’s nice to know that the Philippine Chamber of Commerce and Industry (PCCI) is fighting PPA on this issue. But they need the support of the larger society in this struggle. What’s at stake here is no less than the global competitiveness of the entire Philippine economy.

Sunday, February 18, 2007

Philippine economy on the mend

Asia Times Online article
By David L Llorito
Posted Oct 26, 2006

MANILA - Philippine President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo may be suffering politically, with allegations of vote-rigging and state-sponsored human-rights abuses darkly hanging over her embattled administration. But the economist-turned-president is simultaneously riding a rising tide of good economic news, which is significantly shoring up her government's staying power.

In the first seven months of this year, net foreign direct investments registered with the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP), the Philippine central bank, reached US$1.15 billion, a 60% jump over the same period last year. Led by US, Japanese, German and British investors, foreign funds are pouring into manufacturing, led by outlays into paper, chemicals, electronics and steel, as well as services, including business process outsourcing, tourism, engineering and construction.

Healthy capital inflows are boosting the local bourse. Francis Ed Lim, president and chief executive officer of the Philippine Stock Exchange, notes that the stock market has recently reached highs not seen since the heady days preceding the 1997-98 Asian financial crisis. "I am sure fiscal reforms in the government have made us an attractive investment alternative," Lim told Asia Times Online. He contends that listed companies are expected to turn in bumper profits this year, due largely to the country's improving economic fundamentals.

In the past two-and-a-half years, as measured by gross domestic product (GDP) figures, real economic growth has averaged between 5% and 6% and state economic planners are confident the trend will continue this year and over the medium term. Foreign remittances, which are on pace to top $12 billion this year, still contribute disproportionately to domestic consumption and total GDP. However, economists contend that recent economic growth has been more broad-based, with agriculture and industry contributing more in percentage terms than in the past.

That performance has set Arroyo's spin doctors in upbeat motion. "The economy is on an extended bull run and we are confident that the people can keep the pace going until we finally achieve economic takeoff," she recently said to a meeting of local and foreign business people, where she attempted to drum up $3 billion of new investments.

Romulo Neri, director general of the National Economic and Development Authority (NEDA), says that apart from the $30 billion export-oriented electronics and cyber-services industry, new growth drivers such as agribusiness, marine products, mining and tourism, among others, will boost average expansion to around 7% by 2010, potentially putting the Philippines on par with fast-growing China, India and Vietnam.

More soberly, multilateral agencies credit the government's reform policies for the improved performance, particularly those measures that Arroyo implemented soon after the controversial 2004 presidential election. The International Monetary Fund (IMF) recently noted that until recently the Philippines had suffered from "policy drift", which resulted in mushrooming public debt and unwieldy external financing obligations. That, the IMF said, had left the economy vulnerable to both internal and external shocks.

Since 2004, Arroyo has undertaken significant belt-tightening reforms, including boosting the value added tax rate from 10% to 12%, the corporate tax rate and excise levies, which combined have substantially narrowed the fiscal deficit and stabilized national finances. Non-financial public sector deficit was slashed from 5.3% of GDP in 2003 to 2% of GDP by the end of 2005. Those reforms have importantly freed up funds for priority spending, including badly needed outlays for new infrastructure.

They've also helped to rein in galloping inflation, which has dipped from around 7.5% last year to currently below 6%. Those improving fundamentals have made the peso one of Asia's best-performing currencies this year, up more than 10% against the greenback, year-on-year as of mid-October. Some local and foreign analysts predict that the country is due for a sovereign risk upgrade, which the country hasn't seen for over nine years.


Good news, bad newsAt the same time, independent economic analysts say there is a drastic need for further reforms, and some fear that the recent spate of good economic news could lead to complacency. "There are clear positive developments in the economy. However, the picture continues to be a mix of good news and bad news, marked with a number of puzzling contributions," said Cielito Habito, economist from the Ateneo Center for Economic Research and Development, and former NED director general during the presidency of Fidel Ramos from 1992-98.

"Of the three key variables that matter most - prices, jobs and incomes - prices and incomes are showing some improvements, but the already bad jobs situation has gotten even worse," said Habito. He notes that despite strong economic expansion, new employment grew by only 2.3%, lagging the annual 2.6% expansion of the labor force, which has resulted in higher unemployment, now at around 2.9 million potential workers.

Habito also notes that despite the improving economic fundamentals, consumer and business confidence are still in the doldrums, due to the ongoing political crisis, rising unemployment and, in places, ineffective government stimulus. According to the BSP, consumer confidence in the third quarter was a negative 37%, worryingly unchanged from the second quarter. Rising global crude prices and increasing local labor costs, meanwhile, have hit business confidence, which declined from 31.6% in the second quarter to 21.7% in the third quarter of this year.

Government officials contend that recent reforms will take time to trickle down. "I think it's a hangover from last year's political crisis," said Dennis Arroyo, executive director of NEDA's national policy and planning, who is not related to President Arroyo. Election rigging allegations against Arroyo have recently led to mass street demonstrations, the resignation of 10 cabinet members and widespread rumors of a military takeover, which motivated the embattled president to declare a state of emergency in February.

"Remember that investment decisions lag by at least six months. Those [political events] are still impacting us. So there's an investment lag," said NEDA's Arroyo, who contends that once government spending kicks in for the third and fourth quarters, the private sector would be encouraged to accelerate their investment decisions. "We are well on our way to a 5.8% to 6.6% growth in 2007 and about 7.3% by 2010," said the official.

Other independent economists, however, are less optimistic. Joachim von Amsberg, the World Bank's country director in the Philippines, contends that an unresolved "paradox" is adversely affecting the economy's performance.

The Philippines, he said, is located in a "great neighborhood" of booming East Asian economies, with educated and English-speaking people, abundant natural resources and some strong and dynamic sectors like electronics and cyber-services. "Yet its growth rate has been below potential," von Amsberg said, noting that until now growth has been driven more by foreign remittances than domestic investment or rapidly expanding exports.

"Output per worker in the Philippines is up 50% between 1961 and 2003 as compared to 450% in other East Asian economies. It's not due to differences in educational attainment or human capital, but it's due to lower physical capital accumulation and productivity growth," he said. He contends that Arroyo needs to pursue a clearer, deeper reform agenda, which aims to ensure the credibility of contracts, open and competitive bidding for infrastructure projects, deregulate key economic industries and liberalize the financial system.

"Continuous attention should be given to reducing transactions costs through eliminating red tape, simplifying the adjudication process, and strengthening the integrity and capability of key regulatory institutions," he said. Clearly there is still much work to be done before the Philippines enters the ranks of Asia's powerhouse economies. Yet, slowly but surely, barring another major political hic-cup, the economic picture is improving.

(Copyright 2006 Asia Times Online Ltd. All rights reserved. Please contact us about sales, syndication and republishing .)

Wednesday, February 14, 2007

Philippine cement industry: say it ain't so, Peter!

WE support Trade and Industry Secretary Peter Favila’s efforts to get to the bottom of the supposed spikes in cement prices. We are entering the summer months, the start of the construction season, and we can’t afford to unduly penalize the construction sector that is just starting to recover since the Asian financial crisis in 1997.

If there’s one sector that can really make a difference in the lives of many ordinary people in the quickest time possible, it’s the construction industry. It’s a labor-intensive industry that soaks up lots of jobless brawn off the streets as soon as people decide to build buildings, industrial plants and homes.

Taking off from Favila’s lament, it’s indeed curious that a 40-kg bag of cement now reportedly costs P200, when sales are supposedly low. That seems to violate the basic concept of the law of supply and demand. He threatened to import cement should the spikes continue, if only to protect consumers. It’s a sensible policy we say, given that there is now a pressing need to bring down to the masses the benefits of modest growth that we have achieved in recent years.

But why should the government resort to such action? We have checked with the Tariff Commission and we have found out that the government has removed the special safeguards measures (SSM) that former trade secretary Mar Roxas had applied on cement imports long ago.

In 2001, Roxas caved in to the local cement lobby that was then complaining about “injuries” caused by rising cement imports and was forced to impose SSM, thus significantly raising cement prices in the local market. In response, the Tariff Commission conducted an investigation and found out that Roxas’s decision was totally baseless, as local manufacturers maintained an 80-percent share of the domestic market. The report also stated that there was no injury to speak of, nor was there any worker losing his job because of the rise of cement imports. The industry, in fact, improved its productivity as a result of the rising foreign competition.

Thus, right now cement enjoys a low tariff of 5 percent. Given that anybody could actually import the stuff now without any other trade barrier, it’s probably unnecessary for the government to threaten local cement producers with imports.

Is Favila grandstanding? We are asking this question because, given the low tariff rates for cement (5 percent), it’s possible that the recent rise in domestic prices is the result of market forces. In the last four quarters, the gross value added of the construction sector has been growing within the range of 3.5 percent to 5.2 percent.

Lately, analysts have been saying that the property sector is due for a boom in response to certain structural factors like rising remittances, rising investment inflows, and the continuing demand for office spaces by the business-process outsourcing industry. Certainly, under a competitive environment, an increase in local prices could immediately trigger either rising production or imports, as suppliers try their best to capture the windfall gains. In just a short while, prices will stabilize again to the benefit of consumers.

So why worry? Why the threat of flooding the local market with cement imports?

Unless Favila knows something that we don’t.

The only way local cement prices could rise above what the market would allow is when producers, as well as importers, collude to take advantage of the coming construction boom. Certainly, a lot of cement-industry stakeholders are salivating at the prospect of making easy money from the projected 20-percent property growth in 2007. But is collusion possible considering that there are many producers and suppliers?

Consider this report from the Tariff Commission: “After 1997, faced with a shrinking market and financial problems, the local companies were ripe for the picking. They were looking for investors or partners as their ‘knights in shining armor’ to save them from their financial woes. The attractiveness of the local cement companies was something that the international players could not ignore.

“Given the cement companies’ dire straits and given the fact that the peso had depreciated considerably vis-à-vis the dollar, given that new plants were now being put up or going on stream, given the foreign cement companies’ experience in other countries of achieving market dominance, and given the openness of the local owners to foreign investments, the time had come for the global companies to enter the Philippine market in a big way. The local companies could be had at bargain, if not basement, prices. Between 1997 and 1999, Blue Circle, Cemex, Holcim and Lafarge took over 12 companies which now control 89 percent of total industry capacity.”

There you go! What we have here is a concentrated industry where a few companies control the bulk of the local market. There are importers of course, but they actually just account for 13 percent of the domestic market. And in the context of the Philippine political economy where every big shot is a relative, kumpare or a fraternity brother of the niece or the balae of the other, collusion might be one issue here.

We actually hope there is no such collusion; nor do we assume such malevolence. But what we stress here is that indeed Peter Favila, a guardian of public interest when it comes to trade and consumer affairs, has a serious job to do here. And do he must in the most transparent of ways. If he sees collusion somewhere down the road of inquiry, he must let the public know.

To quote Ralph Waldo Emerson (1803-1882): “Each man takes care that his neighbor shall not cheat him. But a day comes when he begins to care that he does not cheat his neighbor. Then all goes well—he has changed his market-cart into a chariot of the sun.”


Yes, we need the powers of the state to help make sure some guys out there who do business would indeed change their market carts into chariots of the sun.

Thomas Barnett's Pentagon's New Map

For all those who want to understand globalization in the time of Terror, this book by Thomas Barnett is an excellent reference. His use of the first person perspective and conversational tone makes the discussions of global affairs easy to digest. But this book is not a convenient read especially for those who see America as playing a negative role in international politics. Americans may also find his recommendations discomforting as his views of the world leaps out of the usual boxes set by the commentariat from both conservative and the liberals. But I must admit that I find his “core-gap” thesis pretty attractive as a way to analyze global events.

The book argues that the world is in a mess because globalization has largely benefited the Core (composed of countries like the US, Europe) and the new core (essentially China, India, Brazil, and the newly industrialized countries) with the rest of the world especially the gap (Third World hell holes where terrorists hide and spawn) isolated and disconnected, their faces pressed against the glass. The task of the Core (necessarily led by the US and Europe) should extend connectedness to the rest of the world by balancing “four major global transactions.”

First is the movement of people from the Gap through the Core to address the greying population problem and its attendant issues. Second transaction is the movement of energy (oil, gas) to the Core and new Core. Third transaction is the movement of capital (investments, foreign trade) from the Core to the new core and the gap. China and the Asia Pacific region is certainly benefiting from this trend. And the last is the export of “security” from the Core to the gap.

This one is the most contentious. One the one hand, US presence in East and Southeast Asia has prevented a regional arms race, thus enabling countries like Korea, Singapore, Thailand, Malaysia, Japan, and the Philippines to focus their resources on economic development. Humanitarian operations to help countries affected by natural disasters are also seen as positive. On the other, the continuing bloodletting in Iraq seems to point out towards the dangers of exporting security especially in areas where American presence is not welcome.

Nevertheless, his arguments for ending disconnectedness and isolation by Gap countries are powerful. And I wonder why its recommendations don’t seem to reflect American economic and trade policy especially during the time when American leadership is needed to make the Doha Round of Trade negotiations successful. Maybe it’s because the conservatives and the Republicans are simply stuck in the Iraqi quagmire to think of other more important “global transactions.” That’s the tragedy. But that doesn’t detract us from the fact that this book is a nice one to read.

Tuesday, February 13, 2007

Signs of the times in the Philippines

Am I a lousy supervisor or what? Last New Year’s eve, I lost Debbie to a call center company where she assumed a managerial post. Yesterday, on Valentines’ eve, Louise handed her resignation letter, telling me she is joining a market research firm next month. And the reasons? Both of them got 50-100 percent higher pay.

“Are you sure that’s [higher pay] really the reason why you are leaving?, I asked.

“Yes, sir,” she said. We have been friends for long and I see no reason why she should lie to me.

“That’s nice,” I said. “I’m happy for you. I don’t see why I should get in the way of people’s progress and happiness. Congratulations!”

“Thank you, sir!”

It’s unfortunate for me because her resignation would further disrupt some of our research projects. Overall, however, I’m happy because it means that job opportunities out there are increasing and young people like her are getting better options. In the past, some staff members resigned because they either hated me or got sick and tired of my face. They would rather go jobless or get lower pay somewhere just to stop seeing my shadow. Now, they resign because they have better offers. Isn’t that wonderful?

Signs of the times really and a nice one at that. In the last three to five years, the Philippine economy has been growing 5-6 percent and somehow this consistent albeit modest growth are slowly transforming into tangible gains like rising job opportunities. The growth of cyberservices, electronics, finance, telecommunications, and real estate as well as the continuing inflow of dollars from overseas workers (12-14 billion US dollars a year) are apparently generating lots of economic activities. It’s not yet The Promised Land, but things are moving forward.

Meantime, I need to get a replacement.

Monday, February 12, 2007

Could the Philippines ever have an "issue-oriented" politics?

Count a few more days and soon we will see our communities being swamped by strangers who will shake our hands, kiss our babies, and promise to ease our pains and take away our sorrows.

We laugh at their antics, sneer at their pretensions, and get entertained by the platoons of clowns and scantily-clad girls they foist on the stage to get our attention. But in the end, their kind are going to have the last laugh for they will determine whether or not our garbage are collected, our towns and cities enjoy peace and stability, and our country grow and prosper. It’s really important therefore that we choose the right candidate to elect. No, we are not talking here about ideology or whether or not the guy hates globalization and loves an “ism”; we are talking about integrity, honesty and competence.

Why integrity and competence and not the issues? It’s because “issue-oriented politics” in the Philippine seem to have gone passé. But still we long for the “politics of principles and ideologies” and are disgusted by the current crop of candidates who don’t mouth the key words we always long to hear. These include the old left-leaning trigger words like “nationalism,” “cause-oriented,” “pro-people,” “pro-environment,” “against foreign debt,” “nationalist industrialization,” “land reform,” “against globalization,” to name a few.

But we no longer hear these words and we wonder if politics has completely gone down to the level of That’s Eentertainment or Starstruck. Maybe it has. But real reason could be that the kind of political process that those key words represented was long gone. Globalization has completely changed the references of political and social discourse thus making the old framework about what is Left and what is Right, from which the great debates have been traditionally anchored here in the Philippines, totally irrelevant.

In the formulation of yore, denizens of the left shade of the political spectrum long for change and embrace the flow of history in contrast with those of the Right who cling to the status quo. Not anymore. These days, for instance, the Left instinctively oppose market-oriented legislations that could undo local monopolies and oligopolies and therefore benefit consumers and the broader segment of the masses. Confused about their loyalties, leftists conveniently link arms with military adventurists and Marcos remnants for whatever issue they find convenient to oppose. How easy it is for human right activists these days to form “tactical alliances” with their former torturers, thus blurring the imagined political fault lines of the recent past.

It’s the collapse of Berlin Wall that ushered in the faster pace of globalization that brought all this confusion and change. Class struggle within the country’s borders, the imagined schism between the owners of capital and the possessor of the brawn, has lost its immediacy as both workers and capitalists suddenly found themselves struggling for survival against foreign competition. Suddenly, “global competitiveness” became the buzzword requiring strategic alliances and cooperation between the state, politicians, the business community, the working class, and civil society. It was the “end of history,” proclaimed political scientist Francis Fukuyama, the end grand theorizing; the business is now is about the nitty-gritty of fostering greater liberal democracy, growth and development the boring process and path for which hardly brings up contentious or bitter debates.

That explains the reason why we could no longer hear politicians and political players argue about grand ideas and competing models of development. With globalization in full throttle, the current crop of politicians now generally assume the future of the country lies in connectivity, and the only debate left is to what extent and how fast should we hitch on that global dynamics. But that these differences by themselves wouldn’t make interesting election discussions as politicians would rather go for mass marketing techniques characterized by hype and spectacle to get the most number of votes.

To some extent, the “success” of the post-Marcos reformers explains the characteristics how we do politics today. Many of the leaders that brought the Edsa Revolution became functionaries of the state even until the present, bringing with them their language of activism and protest. Terms like “sustainable development,” “bottom-up approach,” and “people-centered approach” to development became mainstream terminologies that everybody subscribe to.

The worst aspect of the post-Edsa reforms of course was the discrediting of the traditional party system through a systematic campaign against the “traditional politician” or trapo. That one really undermined the party system that in a functioning democracy should be the ideal avenue for political socialization and mobilization. The queen of the Edsa Revolution herself, Corazon Aquino, thrashed the credibility of the party system by dumping the archetypal traditional politician in Ramon Mitra in favor of Fidel Ramos, a military hero who by that time looked like “non-traditional politician,” despite an earlier gentlemen’s agreement that each aspirant would be abide by the results of the primaries within the Laban ng Demokratikong Pilipino.

Ramos then looked like a non-trapo simply because the post-Edsa reformers never really succeeded in defining what the alternative to trapo was. From the popular imagination, traditional politicians are those who have always been there since time immemorial and that definition damaged even the likes of Jovito Salonga, Teofisto Guingona, and Aquilino Pimentel. With the credibility of the party system and traditional politics in tatters, the stage was set for the next crop of “non-trapo” leaders like the actor Joseph Estrada and Gloria Arroyo whose rose to power in the most nontraditional means. Cory’s action in anointing Ramos then simply confirmed that parties has always been flags of convenience that could be easily discarded once the direction of political winds changed.

It was plain naïveté for post-Marcos reformers to concoct the term “non-traditional politicians because in reality all politics are traditional. Politics in its barest essential—no matter what that politician’s motive is—is all about the capture and maintenance of political power. A reformer has to capture power first even he or she could ever dream of implementing well meaning social policies. The thrust after the Edsa Revolution therefore would have been reengineering and strengthening the party system the way the Americans and the Europeans did and not denigrating it without offering any alternative. Revitalizing the party system of course would take time but the Filipino nation and its social institutions could actually start the process by reemphazing the values that made political parties relevant and effective: competence, honesty, and integrity.

Sunday, February 11, 2007

People power through microcredit

A few weeks ago, former president Corazon Aquino launched what could probably be the largest single private sector microcredit program in the country’s history. Called PinoyME or Filipino Micro-Enterprise, the program aims to mobilize P5 billion pesos to assist 5 million poor entrepreneurs in depressed communities all over the country. Philippine society should support this program for three major reasons.

First, the program represents a major shift in thinking among the country’s economic elites about the potentials of the poor and marginalized sectors of society as agents of development and progress. For long, managers of banks and financing organizations looked down on the poor as “unbankable.”

The poor usually have nothing to offer as collateral. They don’t have stable jobs, nor do they have good resume. In developing countries like the Philippines, they often derive irregular incomes from economic activities (e.g. farming, peddling) that are considered high-risk and seasonal. They have no credit history that the banks could verify. And yet, Cory and her group are embarking on a program that is certainly risky and yet has the potential of transforming the country’s economy.

Of course, since Mohammed Yunus got a Nobel Prize for the success of the Grameen Bank that he founded in Bangladesh, bankers and financiers have started to realize that there is business in banking with the poor, especially women.

In fact, bankers these days have started to change their phraseology about microfinance: it’s not the poor are “unbankable”; they are simply “pre-bankable” and microcredit—given factors like adequate social preparation like training in entrepreneurship, value formation, and effective community organizing—could be the best way of bringing them into the mainstream of the country’s financial system. Once they are able to build “track record,” the poor are likely to be as reliable a partner of the banks as those who do their business from their posh offices along Ayala Avenue in Makati.

Second, micro-credit programs such as PinoyME are probably the best way to ensure gender equality in the Philippines. Based on the experiences of Yunus’ Grameen Bank as well as other schemes worldwide, microcredit programs are oftentimes focused on women. Why women? It’s because, based on actual experiences, loans extended to women and their projects are likely to benefit the entire family more than when these are extended to men.

And third, economic and social programs such as this one could help ensure broad-based growth in the Philippines. If it succeeds, it has the potential of uplifting the lives of a least 5 million poor families all over the country. Some of them may eventually grow into small and medium enterprises, create more jobs in their localities, and transform a lot more lives in the process. In the last twelve quarters, the Philippine economy has been growing at decent growth rates (5-6 percent gross domestic product growth rates), driven mostly by robust performances of electronics, outsourcing, and consumption-oriented economic activities buttressed by the dollar remittances of overseas Filipino workers. Initiative such as PinoyME therefore is a good way of complimenting these sectors, boosting the economy even more. In fact, if we want to broaden the ranks of the middle class, microcredit is probably one of the best ways to do it.

The expansion of the ranks of the middle class is important because of its role in strengthening the country’s democratic institutions. Former Negro Occidental governor Daniel Lacson sums it well, thus: “By making microfinance more accessible, PinoyME aims to unlock the potential of individual Filipinos, particularly those who have been marginalized and stripped of their dignity by sheer poverty. Over the medium to long term, this will also pave the way for better governance as a critical mass of citizens is empowered to make mature political choices and demands, as well as to aspire to become a new breed of leaders. Our vision is to help create a broad middle class, which is the foundation for an equitable economy and a strong democracy.”

Thursday, February 08, 2007

Globalization and the Philippines: "The walls are within us"

Two weeks ago, Dana (a journalist friend from a Japanese wire agency) and me were discussing “globalization” in reaction to Thomas Friedman’s book The Lexus and the Olive Tree. Last Monday, I was surprised to get an email from her detailing some of her recent comments. The points she raised are interesting.

Dear Dave:

1. You said you dream of an information age where information would be readily available to people, so people can improve their lives by making informed decisions. Friedman talks about a world where information is available at the click of a mouse, but my question is, can this be done?

2. Technology has made information available to a lot of people, and it has also kept out a lot of people. But if you think of it, poverty and lack of knowledge are the not only walls we have built. We keep information to ourselves because it is power, and we trade it as we do money.

3. Sometimes, people are afraid to say what they know because they fear persecution, from those who would lose their power if the information were to be publicly known. Sometimes they feel that no one would listen anyway. In our day to day lives, do we readily share information with anyone who would like to know? Or do we check first if the person is worth our trust? If we think of information as dangerous, and believe that even the smallest detail can be twisted and used against us, will we ever come to a time when information will be freely shared?

4. We are the ones who make the technology, we are the ones who build the walls. And we are the ones who choose not to share. For as long as we continue to distrust each other, for as long as we build walls to keep strangers out, we will not have an information age, regardless of the technology. For always there will be some who will be left out, by the walls that have been built.

5. Ursula leGuin, in her novel "Dispossessed," talks of an ideal society, one where they tried not to build walls. There were no laws, no properties, no incentives save the satisfaction of doing the work that one liked and the respect of one's neighbors. There was no religion, no taboos. Sex was not forbidden, and people had no idea of heaven or hell. Yet still they built walls: in their hearts and in their minds, they clung to the ideas they knew, to the comfort of customs and traditions, and tried to keep strangers out. The walls are inside us. We will not be ready to share until we see each other as brothers. So the information age you dream about is not about technology, it is about sharing. And it will come about when we are ready, not when the technology is.

Comments? Reactions? Violence
?

It seems that these are existential questions whose answers hang in the realm subjective thoughts and feelings. But let me try in my own way.

1. It could be done, why not? But there are certain conditions like the ubiquity of broadband and the greater affordability of these technologies. Policy-wise, we need to open up telecommunications and media industries to greater competition. We need to allow 100 percent media ownership in media. We need to dismantle the oligopoly in these sectors.

2. Poverty and lack of knowledge is somehow one and the same. Many people are poor because they lack access to information and knowledge. When you are information poor, you don’t have a choice. And choice is the essence of development, right? Right. And where do you start? With education, with reforms in telecommunications and media ownership. Some information are actually “free”; notice the proliferation of open source software and user generated content. But there’s really no worry about the trading of information and knowledge. If you could trade and make money from these things, there are more incentives for you to acquire them, process, and sell them as value added contribution to society. Going to school and working as journalist, analyst, or engineer later on are examples of how we trade knowledge and ideas in return for something that we value, be it money, prestige, and power.

3. Information and knowledge per se are always neutral. If someone twists it for certain ends, the solution is only greater openness. That’s how you expose the malicious, the fake, and the plain dimwits. That’s the rationale for encouraging greater competition in the economy. When there are competing sources of information, and greater freedom of the press and information, there are greater chances that those who are manipulating the truth are exposed and pay for it.

4. For me the key word there is choice, as always. People should have the right to give and withhold information, subject to certain legal limitations. But that’s not really a problem. What is crucial is the question whether or not the social dispensation allow such freedoms, whether or not The System allows or bans the technologies that ensures people have access to information that they seek. But mind you, people—as proven by the growth of blogging, Youtube, and social networking like Multiply—would really like to share. It appears to be part of human nature. The Internet it appears is breaking lots of barriers, including distrust.

5. This year’s Time of the Year is “You.” Or “we” who are there transforming information and knowledge through open source, user provided content, etcetera. Isn’t that enough proof that LeGuin is wrong? There would always be people who would try to build walls but these barriers are going to be shattered by the innate desire to share, to reach out, and connect. Yes, the information revolution is really all about connectivity.


I really hope I answered her questions.